the better truth

the better truth
Showing posts with label jake gyllenhaal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label jake gyllenhaal. Show all posts

Thursday, November 27, 2014

Nightcrawler (2014)

Nightcrawler (2014)
Portrait of a CEO as a Young Man

 …in the midst of a war that was selfish, ruthless and cruel Sammy was proving himself the fittest and the fiercest and the fastest.”
― Budd Schulberg, “What Makes Sammy Run?”

This is just like television, only you can see much further.
― Chance the Gardener riding in a car for first time from Jerzy Kosinski’s “Being There”

“Nightcrawler” is a film depicting the meteoric rise of a sociopathic freelance news cameraman who specializes in recording crime related carnage. The premise is unsettling but the real terror lies in Dan Gilroy’s ability to take this work out of the low earth orbit of the thriller/action/horror genres. This film has more in common with the seminal “Network” than “Silence of the Lambs”. Certainly Hannibal Lector is scary but Louis Bloom, played masterfully by Jake Gyllenhaal, is a more pernicious type of monster. The former enjoys being a devil, Bloom sees happiness as something that gets in the way of the real reason for existence, profit.  Gilroy manages, amidst car chases, bloody bodies and Bloom’s eyeball-rolling grins, to give a commentary on the dangers of our distracted culture. It is an art-house film posturing successfully as a mainstream feature with ironic warnings against the perils of entertainment and the banality of corporate careerism.  Gilroy never preaches. The repulsiveness of Bloom’s vision is exposed in a carefully calibrated climb up the entrepreneurial ladder. Bloom never engages in overt violence, but his actions are as disturbing as Lector’s cannibalism. An audience member might consider an encounter with a deranged serial killer to be a matter of luck. That same movie-goer knows there is no escaping the endless smiling junior achievers, salesmen and corporate shills. Louis Bloom is the embodiment of the unforgiving fine print. There is no way out except endless vigilance. Louis means business.

The casting in “Nightcrawler” is superb. Bloom's hard luck ‘partner’ in his news gathering start up, played by Riz Ahmed, provides a startling contrast for Gyllenhaal’s unstoppable appetite for domination. Each encounter exponentially illustrates the former’s callowness and the latter’s savagery. The final sequence culminates in Riz’s sheepish attempt at taking a stand. This is met by Gyllenhaal’s channeling all the contempt of corporate flack by saying that Riz’s failure to meet agreed upon performance requirements will result in physical harm. Riz caves to the bullying thereby sharing the fate of every minimum wage slave or under-educated plaintiff caught in the rigged trap of economic desperation. His fate is sealed with his unvarnished honesty in verbally disclosing that there is something very very very wrong with his boss and the overall situation. Expressing doubt in your leader’s vision is a capital offense as is the crime of competing too well… just ask the rival news stringer played wonderfully by Bill Paxton. Louis not only dispatches him by jimmying his truck but, to the horror of Riz, records the aftermath of the crash. The old, defeated veteran is loaded into the ambulance while Louis leans over with a cam corder. This is a visual metaphor for those who fail to understand the new dimensions of a competitive marketplace. The only way to survive Louis is to get out of the way or get in bed with him. The latter is the strategy employed by Rene Russo who embodies the mean-spirited vulgarity of local TV news. The old adage, “if it bleeds it leads”, has been replaced by, in the words of the news director, “a hysterical screaming white woman running down the street”. The mealy mouthed news staff might be appalled but everyone knows that she is bringing home the bacon with Louis’s endless supply of snuff films. Russo worn mascara, cigarette stained physicality matches Gyllenhaal’s skeletal creepiness. She plays at being Louis but in the end she knows she’s is a low ratings week away from being featured as a victim one of her leading news stories. Her better self is repelled by Louis but like Lady Anne before her, she ends up falling for Richard III. Maybe Lewis could toss her off the roof of the studio and film it in slow motion. It sounds unlikely but it is the inevitable direction of all their hard work.

Gilroy fills this feature with unorthodox small moments of revelation. Lewis’s complete derangement shows through in polished speeches about being a “hard worker” and “quick learner”. But it glows in the quieter moments. In an early scene a scrap yard manager is accepting Louis’ delivery of stolen metal. He quickly dismisses Louis’ plea of a job. “I’m not hiring a thief”.  Louis is not offended. Anger only clouds the path to profit. He almost thanks the man for his candor. This “feedback” is something he can use. Perhaps the most poignant moment is a brief view of Louis at home. Casually taking part in Ellinor Rigby type domestic chores (dawning socks and ironing). He views a  slap-stick routine on one of the channels. A knight in full armor is seemingly decapitated -followed by the reveal that the suit of armor was inhabited by a petite woman who pops here head through the shoulders after the helmet flies off. Louis, for the first and only time in the entire film, roars with laughter. It is the type of humor more suited to a eight year old boy or an eighty year old man; then again the apartment is decorated with the same pre-adolescent or late geriatric sensibility.  An antiseptic, sparsely decorated room dominated by a TV. Our monster appears, to paraphrase Shakespeare,  unfinished sent before his time… scarce half made up. It is hard to feel anything for someone so depraved but the site of him in that cubicle of a living space almost provokes sympathy. Note: despite receiving an economic windfall from his perverted news-gathering, he remains living in his cell. He will get a nice mansion when his career requires it, not before. It might appear to be the same flashy style as his spiritual brother from “There Will Be Blood” but it is doubtful that he will end up braining an old friend to death in the basement. That would require passion. Louis only possesses drive.

Speaking of drive this film has a wonderful chase scene that is as disorienting as the the idea that Louis is a mammal. In most film bad guys chase good guys or vice versa. This dynamic car sequence has weird guys chasing good guys chasing bad guys. The swerves and crashes are shot from the POV of Louis and his cohort - but where is the audience’s allegiance? One wishes our anti-hero a worse fate than the erstwhile ‘bad guys’ who have brutally murdered an innocent family in cold blood. Such is the logic in a world in which Louis is winning.

Gilroy needs to be credited with producing an excellent film but it is not without flaws. The opening title sequence displayed Robert Elswit Hopper-esque picture of LA. One could hear Jim Morrison screaming “cops in cars, topless bars, never met a woman.. so alone”. This promising opening was followed by a slow meandering start. There is a long series of scenes establishing Louis prowess as a ruthless, slick, fast-talking petty thief who stumbles on the news gathering business by the serendipity of witnessing a gruesome car crash. The mechanics of the execution of the material failed to match the remaining 3/4 of the film. It dragged. The problem might lie in the disconnect between Louis’ super human efficiency and his status as a petty thief in the opening sequence. As the film progresses it showcases his extraordinary capacity to mimic and digest vital bits of information. The opaque references to his origins are equally puzzling. Louis has the ‘right’ answer to all questions. He can make up yarns on the spot and speak the language of negotiation whether he is hocking stolen metal, a high end bike or a reel of grizzly footage. When Russo asks about his history he is uncharacteristically taciturn. Where does Louis really come from? Does someone with his demonic skill set end up hocking manhole covers while he’s in his thirties? It might have been better to have Louis enter the movie returning from a prison stint. His lack of circulation might account for his dearth of achievement. The early Louis seems to undercut the diabolical achievements of the latter Louis.  It would also be interesting for him to present, whether real or imaginary, a portrait of his family. It is the kind of thing he would know would be expected in basic remedial human interaction. What would he come up with? Or perhaps a straightforward rendition of the real life origins would be even more disquieting. In watching endless episodes of 48 Hours and other “women in a ditch” TV programs it is apparent that these creatures spring from Ozzie and Harriet’s cradle.

Gilroy also seems rooted in the grimness of Louis’ world view. There is no humor (or sex) in this film. It’s not that the material screams comedy or passion but simply screaming, or more precisely, recording people screaming, fails to deliver the depravity of Louis. Riz might have served as a human foil. He might have feigned a real connection which would have given more gravitas to Louis’ actions at the end of the film. It also might have made eased the unrelenting darkness of our anti-hero. Truth be told Louis is a one note song. It’s a wonderful, albeit discordant, sound so why not ad some brief major chords of humor. One can only imagine Louis at a corporate event trying to impress the suits at headquarters. There is a touch of this as he wanders the newsroom and people know his name. His glad handing and smiling are as tragic/comic as Starkweather at the close of Malick’s “Badlands”. Louis has mastered the affect of being a “just one of the guys” hero while possessing the track record of a cold blooded killer with boundless contempt for humanity. The reality is merely a poor relation to what really matters, image. It is interesting, in this context, that the writers chose to name the protagonist Louis Bloom. Perhaps this is a mirror image of James Joyce’s Leopold Bloom, the central figure in Ulysses. Whereas Joyce journeys into Leopold’s subconscious giving an expansive commentary on the human condition, Gilroy delves into the dearness of Louis’ mind which is akin to stimulus/response Skinner Box. In this case operant conditioning can be entertaining albeit with less of the grand insight given by Joyce. Leopold is a meditation on humanity. Louis is a study in a particular pathology.

Despite some blemishes Gilroy delivers a film with resonance. Although the media, specifically news gathering organizations, takes center stage, there are broader implications to Bloom’s penchant for replacing “news” with fiction. Life is not fiction, it is stranger. A few weeks ago many publications covering the Ebola crisis tapped the screenwriter for the feature film “Contagion” as an appropriate “expert” to deliver commentary on the health crisis. Who needs a bore with an advanced degree epidemiology when Hollywood can spin a colorful yarn. Given this logic the director of the “The Titanic” might be tapped to weigh in on international North Atlantic transport agreements. There are real life consequences to replacing the arduous hard work of understanding with the distraction of entertainment. Know that our current obsession with Kardashian’s butt can render us vulnerable to ending up on a stretcher with Louis’ cam corder hovering overhead.  We must retain our vigilance. We must trust, but verify while always reading the fine print. We must always have a strong counter offer. We must never take our eye (or mind) off the never-end stream of efficient smiling adversaries. This is the new price of civilization, otherwise we will be eaten by night crawlers.  Over two centuries ago Voltaire warned us: “Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities”. One can imagine Louis Bloom hearing these words and exclaiming in a eureka moment: “now you’re giving me something I can work with”.

Wednesday, October 02, 2013

Prisoners (2013)

Minimum Security Confinement

 “Prisoners” is a crime drama that has a running time of 153 minutes. That is three minutes longer than Spielberg’s “Lincoln”. The trailer showed a taught drama surrounding the abduction of two young girls during a Thanksgiving dinner.  My gut told me the story might have been spun in less time than covering the Civil War.... Then again Kurosawa’s crime film “High and Low” took over two hours. Maybe Denis Villeneuve, the director, has the chops to put meat on this bone... Unfortunately he doesn’t.  One of the key elements of suspense movies is.... suspense. Sounds obvious but not to Mr. Villeneuve.

According to IMBD Mr. Villeneuve, “Abandoned an interest in entomology to pursue his love of filmmaking”.  This was revealing. This insect connection explained a great deal regarding Villeneuve’s oeuvre.  Years ago I spent an afternoon in a meadow with an entomologist who explained the Monarch butterflies love of milkweed. From a dramatic POV the scientist had me for the first 15 minutes... but, being a philistine, the second hour was, despite good weather, excruciating.   Villeneuve really surprised... but not in the way he intended.  Imagine making a dramatic feature about the most terrifying experience anyone could imagine, the kidnapping of your child, and the result being... boring. What is even more startling is that the film touches on an interesting premise. What befalls people who are gripped by loss and terror? They abandon their humanity and become as hideous as their tormentor. This theme has been explored on many occasions probably most successfully in Polanski’s “Death and the Maiden”. Villeneuve  and Aaron Guzikowski,  the writer, drop the ball. The film endlessly meanders between crime drama, character study and sociological profile.

“Prisoners” opens with a deer being shot. This is followed by an overbearing, unhinged father played by Hugh Jackman, congratulating his son for the kill as they drive to their modest suburban home. He is a contractor who is under financial stress.... but clearly ‘there is more to the story’. The rest of the family consists of a stay-at-home wife and a young daughter.  They walk over to join their upscale neighbors for a Thanksgiving meal. It is interesting that these two families would be close given the class and racial divide in the US. The other family is made up of an African American Veterinarian and her possibly stay-at-home husband. Their children are the same age. It would have been interesting to know how these families bonded but Villeneuve has bigger fish to fry... or should say I say, a turkey to cook. We witness the meal and TV watching, a brief walk with the kids.... an encounter a strange van...  back to TV....  the couples tell stories.... the Vets husband takes out a trumpet - which he can’t play (ha ha ha)...  Are you on the edge of your seat? I wasn’t. The audience can be thankful noone said “Let’s play Yahtzee” - that might have been another five minutes of torment. Maybe North American suburban family rituals are interesting to residents of Burma, the Sudan or Micronesia. I think I can represent my 300 million fellow moviegoers and say that ennui was the prevailing mood in the theater . So we are at the 15 or 20 minute mark: AND THEN THE TWO LITTLE GIRLS GO MISSING. Okay we’re finally reaching cruising altitude for the story. But remember the would-be entomologist has to illustrate the point. There is a five minute sequence of: “Are the girls in the basement? - show scene of everyone looking in basement. Maybe the girls are outside? - show everyone outside.  Maybe the girls went to the other house? Show father walking back to his house.... Are you on the edge of your seat? I wasn’t. In fact I felt like screaming: “Would someone f***king call the police!!!!” 

One might counter that a ‘slow start’ is key for setting the cement of the story as in “Psycho”. In that thriller Janet Leigh doesn’t meet Norman till about half an hour in. But the back story of a longtime employee embezzling money adds an erie tension to the scene PRIOR to the madman’s appearance. I have a grave doubt about many things in this world... but here is something of which I am absolutely certain: Villeneuve is no Hitchcock. “Prisoners” opening half hour is laborious fluff. The snippets of exposition might have been added into the opening sequences of Jake Gyllenhaal managing the investigation.  The main take-away is Hugh Jackman is nuts. Well that is completely apparent in his first encounter with the detective. In fact this is hit hard in the first sequence after the deer is downed. Jackman seemed to channeling Capt. Ahab from the jump.  The audience definitely felt for the son as the deer, bleeding in the bed of the pickup, clearly had the better end of the deal on the ride home. I thought all  Hollywood product was audience tested? Note to producers - try taking a scissors to the first 40 minutes and see how the crowd reacts. It is startling that the distributors didn’t put their foot down as a film of  this length complicates the timing of the evening showings. Now that’s a mystery worth investigating.

Back to the scene of the crime. The character of the lead investigator raised the bar.  Gyllenhaal is a solid actor, as were the rest of the cast, but his performance stood out. So finally we’re reaching cruising altitude. Well the bug man forces us to abandon the ole detective and go back to looney daddy. He feels the audience really needs to explore how loose the screw is... Answer: very loose. But not in a way that is dramatically interesting. Once again the idea of evil begetting evil is compelling. The problem is the revenge demon fails to travel very far in Jackman. Watching crazy go crazy is not as interesting as witnessing good go bad. The African American neighbor and wife’s actions are interesting. These people are not inherently pathological. Their badness is rooted in the terror of Milgram’s work on authority figures or Zimardo’s Stanford Prison experiment. The gulf between a ‘normal’ person and a Nazi sadist is uncomfortably close.  Unfortunately Villeneuve focuses on the bad apple. Spending so much time watching Jackman’s sadism leads little time to explore the Vet and her husband or Jake’s subdued rage. Eventually Jake catches revenge fever which leads to assaulting an innocent suspect who commits suicide with the detective's weapon. This would seem a ‘fireable’ offense (no pun intended). Not in this film.  Demotion? Suspension? Weapon confiscated? Nope. The boss gives him a dressing down AND KEEPS HIM ON THE CASE. Chalk it up to artistic license to carry?

This incident leads to the second moment in the film which prompted a desire to scream at the screen. In one of the many convoluted plot twists Jake goes suspect-hunting and bursts into the home of a known sex offender, an old alcoholic priest.  The man is three sheets to the wind so Jake decides to look around. There is  a mummified corpse in the basement which has a distinctive pendent wrapped around its neck.... WHICH MATCHES THE SAME PATTERN AS THE DRAWING THE SUSPECT MADE BEFORE HE SHOT HIMSELF.  Everyone within 500 miles of the theater makes the connection except..... the detective himself. You know the one who, according to some clumsy exposition, ALWAYS solves his cases.  But then as Jake angrily smashes his computer a photograph of the corpse falls to the floor allowing him to make the connection.  In classic Villeneuve fashion it takes about three minutes of screen time before the ‘oh wow’ moment. I mean you wouldn’t want anyone to think the whole thing was too contrived, right?  He has to ‘wait’ to see it... get it?  I was secretly yelling “over there! no, just look! there! THE DRAWING MATCHES THE PENDANT”.  It would be unkind to give away too many storyline details suffice to say that the mummy held many secrets - maybe a movie about the pre-mummy man might have been more interesting. A question for the sphinx?

The tragedy of this film is that there were solid industry craftsman hitting their marks but the key writer/director slots were undecided about what to pursue thematically.  The answer was to tackle everything; which led to a movie about nothing. The trailer hinted at a straightforward cop drama centered around finding the abducted girl. There is a certain amount of linear crime narrative but the creative teams meanders down different roads. It becomes a film about being corrupted by rage but also hints at being a character study of the blue-collar contractor and the detective.  Jackman’s father turns out to have killed himself after a career as a prison guard. The contractor guards this childhood home as a shrine. The detective lets slip he was abused by priests as a child and has distinctive tattoos on his fingers and neck. What is the audience to do with these snippets of biography? How do they relate to the unfolding of the story. In short who are these people? There is a strange opaqueness in this film which ironically gives a tremendous amount of screen time to all these principles. The ever-haunted contractor and the detective seem to be borrowed from other larger character studies and dropped in the middle of this pedestrian crime thriller. The villain is revealed in the end and once again there is a sense of what might have been.... who was this person? The reveal is that they were motivated to take children to spite God and turn people into vengeful demons. The explanation, which would betray too much of the plot, seems forced. Many people experience profound grief but fail to morph into serial child killers. The desire to pair down the film is mixed with an urge to amp up the focus on a particular character. As it is, there is too much combined with not enough.... leaving the audience as adrift as Rosencrantz and Guildenstern witnessing Hamlet. You have a front row seat to all the action but you have no idea what is REALLY going on.  Unlike Shakespeare’s hapless duo you won’t end up executed... but you might wish back those 153 minutes.