the better truth

the better truth

Saturday, October 05, 2013

Salinger (2013)

Arrested Development

“Salinger” is the eponymous documentary about the late American cult writer directed by Shane Salerno. The film is conventional in structure featuring a series of talking heads, archival footage and re-enactments. There is an odd hagiographic bombast undercut by a tabloid sensationalism. The film relishes the dirty details such as inappropriate relationships and mean spirited treatment of loved ones. At the same time counters this by building the great artist myth by treating the bulk of his work as hallowed texts; with more jewels emerging from the grave. The climax has a screen black with large white letters. They carefully spell out the great mysteries the artist’s estate will reveal in the coming decades. This is too important for voice over narration - read the sacred revelations.  Salinger’s last published work, “Hapworth 16, 1924”, was received with a collective groan. That has not whetted the appetite of those who have worshiped his small body of work: a few collections of short stories and the novel “The Catcher in the Rye”; all conceived before 1960.  His book became, for the Post WWII generation, a touchstone of teenage angst.  The purpose of this film is to reveal the man behind these mystical creations. Unfortunately it is merely a gossipy collection of facts with little insight into the person or his works.


Perhaps the nadir of the movie comes with the swelling orchestral music during the ‘triumphant’ reception of the much derided novel. One was expecting to see Rocky Balboa at the top of the stairs. The problem is this also marks the withdrawal of the man from the world.  If this was a story of the writer’s career, the music would be appropriate, but for man himself? One can only think of the Saint Teresa  quote: “Answered prayers cause more tears than those that remain unanswered". Incidentally the first two words of Saint Teresa’s aphorism are the title for the unfinished posthumously published manuscript by another unhappy one-book-wonder, Truman Capote.  The film celebrates the fulfillment of Salinger’s lifelong dream: publication in the New Yorker.  The voice over delivers a surface summation of that story which fails to penetrate the most important aspect of the work - it was a collaboration. The man who, heretofore had ended a friendship with a trusted acquaintance over a small editorial error, was amenable to working with the New Yorkers staff to edit this story.  This tale of suicide, with strong tones of misogyny and sexualization of young girls, was where the author ‘found his voice’. That might be true... but is that a good thing? A close reading of ‘Bananafish’ is almost a roadmap to the life that befell Salinger. He didn’t end up blowing his brains out next to his sleeping wife.  He did, however, scar a number of callow young women who had the misfortune of becoming emotionally close. His prime weapon was total abandonment of his would be partner when he was completely convinced he had the upper hand.  Ironically his literary triumphs give rise to the darkest corner of his nature. Unfortunately Salerno is wedded to the notion that success served the man himself. It certainly made a career but what are we to make of the four friends/acquaintances who end their interviews in tears? These are the few brave souls who came forward as Salinger equated public revelations about their friendship as pure betrayal.  There participation is rooted in wanting to comprehend FOR THEMSELVES what had gone so horribly wrong in their interactions. Unfortunately Salinger felt he alone had ownership of any revelations concerning his person.  Celebrities are often faced with  acquaintances who betray confidences for petty goals such as self-aggrandizement.  Oddly many of the brave souls who bear their hearts are looking for answers in the face of Salinger’s harsh banishment. It is sad that the author never drew the distinction between malevolent gossips and exiled friends.

The subject of his isolation is interesting. Gore Vidal sums it up by saying “he isn’t a recluse at all. He chooses where and when he will interact with the public”. This is true and a peak behind the curtain leads to a unsettling bachelor life akin to Jack Nicholson at the end of “Carnal Knowledge”. That character is so afraid of the “fairer sex” the only interaction possible is a scripted encounter with prostitutes. The low point of Salerno’s exploration concerns his relationship with Joyce Maynard. The pretentious alluring 18 year old came to live withe the 54 year old writer. We can forgive a teenager for believing that she would develop a long-lasting love affair with a misanthropic super-star. It is also difficult to judge him as we learn that he had gone through D-Day, the battle of the bulge and the liberation of a concentration camp. But it probably wasn’t as traumatic for him as the unraveling of their relationship. Their break-up occurs in the same setting as ‘Bananafish’, an upscale Florida beach resort hotel. In real life he shoves her in a cab with two 50 dollars bills - coincidentally Nicholson gives his favorite hooker $100 at the end of “Carnal Knowledge” to signal the end of that assignation.  A Freudian tip? The breakup is fueled by his pronouncement he has no interest in children. Note: they are on a trip with his young son and daughter. She has dreams of procreating with the master. Only a teenager would consider mating with someone who had the family instincts of a spider - but once again this poor woman was barely five years from her thirteenth birthday. She also becomes enraged by Salinger’s habit of soliciting many other extremely young woman by mail. She wasn’t so special after all. The contemporary Maynard clearly isn’t over it. She does two separate interviews, in two separate outfits, at two separate times of day, and doubles down on Salinger as CREEP. Unfortunately the screen-time had an inverse connection to her likability as well as his.   But at least she had grounds to be in the film. What are we to make of the interviews of: Martin Sheen, Ed Norton, Philip Seymour Hoffman, John Cusack.... I guess Vidal Sassoon and Miley Cyrus were too busy to comment? Incidentally Maynard is the second lover who seems to be given a hasty push to the airport. The first is a poor girl who was courted as fourteen year old; only to be given the hook as a young woman when the affair was consummated. Her grief is palpable despite the passage of many decades. Salerno present these unfortunate romances with the notion that Salinger’s inappropriateness stemmed from the horrors of bearing witness as a soldier. Unfortunately this theory conflicts with other factoids which are presented.


Salerno brags about spending a decade of his time and two million dollars in funds in unlocking the mystery of the sphinx. He channels the most callow Salinger worshipers with moment such as: THIS IS THE ONLY KNOWN PHOTOGRAPH OF THE AUTHOR WRITING ‘CATCHER IN THE RYE’ or THIS IS THE ONLY KNOWN FILM FOOTAGE OF J.D. SALINGER AT WAR. The latter clip, an unremarkable silent few seconds of a young J. D. speaking to a group of women and children, is shown TWICE. Salerno does, however, rise above the photographic gimmickry. He delivers two new biographical facts about the man: the post-battle soldier Salinger spent time in a ward after a mental break and briefly married young Nazi woman, whom he brought back to NYC.  This is fascinating, heretofore not generally known information that does give color to Salinger’s life experience. Unfortunately Salerno misinterprets how this correlates to the man and the body of work.  The filmmaker sees the war as creating a harsher, meaner voice for the author.  This fails to jibe with the fact that the central project seems to remain intact throughout the war march. The pre-war and post-battle Holden Caulfield appear to be the same lost cynical soul.  The most profound aspect of Salinger’s oeuvre is his inability to change. There is no reflection given to his monomaniacal obsession with being a great writer.  Salinger labored over “The Catcher in the Rye” and was continually soliciting editors a the New Yorker WHILE WITNESSING THE MOST PROFOUND MILITARY BATTLES OF THE SECOND WORLD WAR... NOT TO MENTION THE LIBERATION OF A CONCENTRATION CAMP. In other words his high school goal of becoming a literary phenomena remained steadfast.  Nothing could shake that dream. His breakdown, given the carnage he witnessed, was understandable. The notion that this in turn gave birth to a new artistic vision in Salinger is debatable.

The relationship with the young German is also open to a radically different interpretation than Salerno’s notion of the author being magnanimous to his enemies.  His marriage might have been related to his pre-war attachment to Oona O’Neill, THE debutant in NYC. Much is made of the fact that she dumped him for the film icon, Charlie Chaplin.  Oona was, in his social circles, the most desirable woman in the world. His second choice of a  German Nazi refugee might be seen as embracing a mirror image of his first love. Salerno delivers some ham-handed lines about Salinger feeling open- hearted forgiveness of the enemy. The problem with that theory is that contrasts with a life built in complete regard for the personal and not the universal. This is a man obsessed with his standing with the New Yorker, his fictional creations and his infatuation with Oona.  Germans were not his enemies. He spent time in Austria before the war training in the meat import business. There are no revelations of personal hatred of specific nationalities. Germans were merely the enemy of the United States. HIS adversaries were anyone who challenged the notion that he was the greatest living writer in the world. His dad, a merchant who was son of a rabbi, was on the list of those skeptical of Salinger’s genius. He was pushing for him to expand his food import business and had sent him to Austria.  Salerno states he was unsupportive of his son’s literary goals. He appears to be a practical man with a practical world view.  It is doubtful he embraced his German Nazi refugee daughter-in-law. He probably had the same reaction his Rabbi father had when he brought home J.D.’s mother - a CATHOLIC.


The hard work of understanding Salinger relies on closely examining his origins. This is someone who only published work written prior to 1960 and even at that point seemed sealed in his adolescent self. What makes this watch tick? Salerno has some curious facts but fails to connect the dots. There is no underscoring of the degree to which Salinger’s parents marriage, a Jew and a Catholic, would have shaken the social norms of the day. Strangely my parents shared the same religious divide a generation later and things were not simpatico on either side of the family. It created a non- identity in myself of being “both” and “neither” simultaneously.   There is another small detail from one of the still photos which also might signal ‘outsider’ status. The film reports that Salinger had a rich kid background. True... to a point. The return address on one his letters shows him to live at Park Ave IN THE UPPER 90s.  For those unfamiliar with the vagaries of NYC real-estate: Park Ave was developed to cover an open railway bed which leads to Grand Central - a key location in many of Salinger’s works. At 96th street the railroad comes above ground and Spanish Harlem begins. Although living on 94th and Park was prestigious - it was far less desirable than living in the prime residential streets - from 60th thru 86th. Ditto for attending McBurney school which was considered less socially desirable than other more exclusive private schools such as Buckley or Collegiate. In other words he was a rich kid with  a prime view of the really rich kids.

One might see Salinger’s hideous ambition to be THE writer stemming from a sense of being an outlier rather than someone observing his peers. The upper end of Park Avenue might not be Napoleon’s Corsica but the fierceness of Salinger’s will to be an artistic genius begs the question: who was he trying to impress? Salinger, growing up rich, knew exactly what money cannot buy. In order to make his mark he drew on something he felt noone could match, his innate ability to write. That is his life’s work even more than the writing itself: proving himself to his crowd especially the neighbors down the street.  Who else would know the references: the clock at the Biltmore Hotel, Choate, fancy mid-town hotel bars.... in short who reads the New Yorker? The film buys into the notion that he was a troubled loner rebel who cast scorn upon the world at large. In reality: his focus was less diverse, his aims less radical and his confidence more intense. He was out to prove himself in a very specific way to a very specific group of people and he never wavered. Such unnatural dedication to a specific end requires a kind of focus found with monks or zealots. This is where Salinger stands apart. He seems born being on a mission to be an important writer by the ‘right’ people. NOTHING would drive him off course.  The film touches on Salinger’s religious journey explaining that he spent a great deal of time with Eastern religious ideas. Given the fact that he was already familiar with Christianity and Judaism one can see an restless search for truth. It has been reported, not in this film, that he flirted with a many unorthodox faiths and health regimes. Certainly living past the age of ninety speaks well for the diets but his spiritual journey is an open question.  Judging by the witnesses to his life, albeit a very select few, he seems someone who sowed a great deal of torment. This unfortunately extends to his daughter who wrote a critical book about her famous dad. She specifically voiced criticism of the central image from his novel: Holden’s dream of catching wayward children from falling of the cliff near the field of rye. She asked an interesting question: where were the parents who let all those children play near the dangerous cliff?  She saw her father as a negligent parent pretending to be a rescuer of those in his charge. Doubling the misfortune the only son dismissed his sister’s account as fiction. They both might be correct in their varied assessments of their father. It is tragic legacy nonetheless.

The final glitzy reveal about the future treasure trove of Salinger titles that have not yet been published confirms a sad truth about the man and his work: he is entombed in a solipsistic journey. There is going to be a volume of HIS interpretations of some Eastern prayers. There will be a story surrounding his romance with the young German Nazi. Finally there will be extensions of characters and stories from the canon. If Salerno’s revelations are true these carefully crafted works, which will be released in a precisely timed manner of Salinger’s choosing, show that his life experience failed to put dent in his set-piece universe. This world and these characters were all conceived by the author in his late teens and early twenties and remained steadfast. There is one exception. The WW II story will be particularly interesting as it might represent an evolution in story and character development. This affair happened at the end of the war - post the creation of the Glass family and Holden. One hopes that the author’s historic journey was digested in terms of the wider world and not just the privileged upper east side. The fear is that it will be through the lens of an alienated young man looking for truth via a callow young woman -  in other words his claustrophobic adolescent fallback POV will dominate.  It’s difficult to know what will come but the topics and manner seem to reveal the unchanging man putting his force of nature against those smart-ass know-it-all phonies who think they rule the world. My humble guess is that the first two volumes will have strong sales. “Hapworth 16, 1924” is an ominous warning.  We see an artist too wrapped up in his truth. That work is an endless monologue from a character who has more meaning for the author than the reader. Ironically the Salerno film is the kind of second rate hero worship that would seem an anathema to Salinger’s creed of being ‘true’. Actually it’s a perfect fit for as his truth forgot the essential lesson of most major religions. Something along the lines of John Donne’s lines:

No man is an island,
Entire of itself,
Every man is a piece of the continent,
A part of the main
.

The irony is that Salinger mistook ‘truth’ for ‘reputation’. Instead of wisdom he seemed to devolve into an angry crank obsessed with the purity of his ‘work’. If that were truth there would be no reason for readers as he would be the arbiter of the work's greatness. But in his case the public was important... not the general public but the Brahmin guardians of artistic merit. All the courting of the literary aristocracy seems to boil down to an unfortunate statement by William Faulkner:

The writer’s only responsibility is to his art. He will be completely ruthless if he is a good one. He has a dream. It anguishes him so much he must get rid of it. He has no peace until then. Everything goes by the board: honor, pride, decency, security, happiness, all, to get the book written. If a writer has to rob his mother, he will not hesitate; the “Ode on a Grecian Urn” is worth any number of old ladies.

In Salinger’s case replace ‘old’ with ‘young’ and you have the essence of his worldview.  It might produce some interesting art - it will no doubt produce an unsympathetic, tormented soul who torments those closest to them. Faulkner had a daughter as well.  As a young woman she begged him to not drink on her birthday. When he did he reprimanded her with:  “Noone remembers Shakespeare’s children”. We can only pray that Jill Faulkner and Margaret Salinger had time to meet in a support group.   Any belief system that values fiction over real relationships is inherently bankrupt; no matter how beautiful the art.  This silly sensationalistic film is in many respects what Salinger feared most - middle brow brush over his valiant life’s work. In Salinger’s mind Salerno might even rank with the unfortunate mentally unbalanced people who have used “Catcher in the Rye” as a manifesto to kill. The film points to a number of these crazies including John Lennon’s assassin. Ironically those pathetic souls fell into the same trap as their beloved author: they replaced  real human beings with an ideology.  Once you extinguish humanity, the world becomes a small desperate, lonely place. As Kurt Cobain put it: “I'm so happy. Cause today I found my friends. They're in my head.” He also ended up having a perfect day for a bananafish.




Wednesday, October 02, 2013

Prisoners (2013)

Minimum Security Confinement

 “Prisoners” is a crime drama that has a running time of 153 minutes. That is three minutes longer than Spielberg’s “Lincoln”. The trailer showed a taught drama surrounding the abduction of two young girls during a Thanksgiving dinner.  My gut told me the story might have been spun in less time than covering the Civil War.... Then again Kurosawa’s crime film “High and Low” took over two hours. Maybe Denis Villeneuve, the director, has the chops to put meat on this bone... Unfortunately he doesn’t.  One of the key elements of suspense movies is.... suspense. Sounds obvious but not to Mr. Villeneuve.

According to IMBD Mr. Villeneuve, “Abandoned an interest in entomology to pursue his love of filmmaking”.  This was revealing. This insect connection explained a great deal regarding Villeneuve’s oeuvre.  Years ago I spent an afternoon in a meadow with an entomologist who explained the Monarch butterflies love of milkweed. From a dramatic POV the scientist had me for the first 15 minutes... but, being a philistine, the second hour was, despite good weather, excruciating.   Villeneuve really surprised... but not in the way he intended.  Imagine making a dramatic feature about the most terrifying experience anyone could imagine, the kidnapping of your child, and the result being... boring. What is even more startling is that the film touches on an interesting premise. What befalls people who are gripped by loss and terror? They abandon their humanity and become as hideous as their tormentor. This theme has been explored on many occasions probably most successfully in Polanski’s “Death and the Maiden”. Villeneuve  and Aaron Guzikowski,  the writer, drop the ball. The film endlessly meanders between crime drama, character study and sociological profile.

“Prisoners” opens with a deer being shot. This is followed by an overbearing, unhinged father played by Hugh Jackman, congratulating his son for the kill as they drive to their modest suburban home. He is a contractor who is under financial stress.... but clearly ‘there is more to the story’. The rest of the family consists of a stay-at-home wife and a young daughter.  They walk over to join their upscale neighbors for a Thanksgiving meal. It is interesting that these two families would be close given the class and racial divide in the US. The other family is made up of an African American Veterinarian and her possibly stay-at-home husband. Their children are the same age. It would have been interesting to know how these families bonded but Villeneuve has bigger fish to fry... or should say I say, a turkey to cook. We witness the meal and TV watching, a brief walk with the kids.... an encounter a strange van...  back to TV....  the couples tell stories.... the Vets husband takes out a trumpet - which he can’t play (ha ha ha)...  Are you on the edge of your seat? I wasn’t. The audience can be thankful noone said “Let’s play Yahtzee” - that might have been another five minutes of torment. Maybe North American suburban family rituals are interesting to residents of Burma, the Sudan or Micronesia. I think I can represent my 300 million fellow moviegoers and say that ennui was the prevailing mood in the theater . So we are at the 15 or 20 minute mark: AND THEN THE TWO LITTLE GIRLS GO MISSING. Okay we’re finally reaching cruising altitude for the story. But remember the would-be entomologist has to illustrate the point. There is a five minute sequence of: “Are the girls in the basement? - show scene of everyone looking in basement. Maybe the girls are outside? - show everyone outside.  Maybe the girls went to the other house? Show father walking back to his house.... Are you on the edge of your seat? I wasn’t. In fact I felt like screaming: “Would someone f***king call the police!!!!” 

One might counter that a ‘slow start’ is key for setting the cement of the story as in “Psycho”. In that thriller Janet Leigh doesn’t meet Norman till about half an hour in. But the back story of a longtime employee embezzling money adds an erie tension to the scene PRIOR to the madman’s appearance. I have a grave doubt about many things in this world... but here is something of which I am absolutely certain: Villeneuve is no Hitchcock. “Prisoners” opening half hour is laborious fluff. The snippets of exposition might have been added into the opening sequences of Jake Gyllenhaal managing the investigation.  The main take-away is Hugh Jackman is nuts. Well that is completely apparent in his first encounter with the detective. In fact this is hit hard in the first sequence after the deer is downed. Jackman seemed to channeling Capt. Ahab from the jump.  The audience definitely felt for the son as the deer, bleeding in the bed of the pickup, clearly had the better end of the deal on the ride home. I thought all  Hollywood product was audience tested? Note to producers - try taking a scissors to the first 40 minutes and see how the crowd reacts. It is startling that the distributors didn’t put their foot down as a film of  this length complicates the timing of the evening showings. Now that’s a mystery worth investigating.

Back to the scene of the crime. The character of the lead investigator raised the bar.  Gyllenhaal is a solid actor, as were the rest of the cast, but his performance stood out. So finally we’re reaching cruising altitude. Well the bug man forces us to abandon the ole detective and go back to looney daddy. He feels the audience really needs to explore how loose the screw is... Answer: very loose. But not in a way that is dramatically interesting. Once again the idea of evil begetting evil is compelling. The problem is the revenge demon fails to travel very far in Jackman. Watching crazy go crazy is not as interesting as witnessing good go bad. The African American neighbor and wife’s actions are interesting. These people are not inherently pathological. Their badness is rooted in the terror of Milgram’s work on authority figures or Zimardo’s Stanford Prison experiment. The gulf between a ‘normal’ person and a Nazi sadist is uncomfortably close.  Unfortunately Villeneuve focuses on the bad apple. Spending so much time watching Jackman’s sadism leads little time to explore the Vet and her husband or Jake’s subdued rage. Eventually Jake catches revenge fever which leads to assaulting an innocent suspect who commits suicide with the detective's weapon. This would seem a ‘fireable’ offense (no pun intended). Not in this film.  Demotion? Suspension? Weapon confiscated? Nope. The boss gives him a dressing down AND KEEPS HIM ON THE CASE. Chalk it up to artistic license to carry?

This incident leads to the second moment in the film which prompted a desire to scream at the screen. In one of the many convoluted plot twists Jake goes suspect-hunting and bursts into the home of a known sex offender, an old alcoholic priest.  The man is three sheets to the wind so Jake decides to look around. There is  a mummified corpse in the basement which has a distinctive pendent wrapped around its neck.... WHICH MATCHES THE SAME PATTERN AS THE DRAWING THE SUSPECT MADE BEFORE HE SHOT HIMSELF.  Everyone within 500 miles of the theater makes the connection except..... the detective himself. You know the one who, according to some clumsy exposition, ALWAYS solves his cases.  But then as Jake angrily smashes his computer a photograph of the corpse falls to the floor allowing him to make the connection.  In classic Villeneuve fashion it takes about three minutes of screen time before the ‘oh wow’ moment. I mean you wouldn’t want anyone to think the whole thing was too contrived, right?  He has to ‘wait’ to see it... get it?  I was secretly yelling “over there! no, just look! there! THE DRAWING MATCHES THE PENDANT”.  It would be unkind to give away too many storyline details suffice to say that the mummy held many secrets - maybe a movie about the pre-mummy man might have been more interesting. A question for the sphinx?

The tragedy of this film is that there were solid industry craftsman hitting their marks but the key writer/director slots were undecided about what to pursue thematically.  The answer was to tackle everything; which led to a movie about nothing. The trailer hinted at a straightforward cop drama centered around finding the abducted girl. There is a certain amount of linear crime narrative but the creative teams meanders down different roads. It becomes a film about being corrupted by rage but also hints at being a character study of the blue-collar contractor and the detective.  Jackman’s father turns out to have killed himself after a career as a prison guard. The contractor guards this childhood home as a shrine. The detective lets slip he was abused by priests as a child and has distinctive tattoos on his fingers and neck. What is the audience to do with these snippets of biography? How do they relate to the unfolding of the story. In short who are these people? There is a strange opaqueness in this film which ironically gives a tremendous amount of screen time to all these principles. The ever-haunted contractor and the detective seem to be borrowed from other larger character studies and dropped in the middle of this pedestrian crime thriller. The villain is revealed in the end and once again there is a sense of what might have been.... who was this person? The reveal is that they were motivated to take children to spite God and turn people into vengeful demons. The explanation, which would betray too much of the plot, seems forced. Many people experience profound grief but fail to morph into serial child killers. The desire to pair down the film is mixed with an urge to amp up the focus on a particular character. As it is, there is too much combined with not enough.... leaving the audience as adrift as Rosencrantz and Guildenstern witnessing Hamlet. You have a front row seat to all the action but you have no idea what is REALLY going on.  Unlike Shakespeare’s hapless duo you won’t end up executed... but you might wish back those 153 minutes.


Sunday, September 22, 2013

Robert Frost: This Verse Business (2013)

Vermont Frost

Lost Nation Theater, a Montpelier Vermont based playhouse,  produced a one man show about Robert Frost. It brings to mind the apocryphal figure who brought coals to Newcastle. What could anyone say about our beloved state icon that we don’t already know? It is de rigueur for any New England higher educational institution to have a black and white photo of the ruffled white haired gentleman shaking hands with the former President of the College or head of the English department. One senses the old man spent his later years on a perpetual reading tour.  He is a superstar whose celebrity eclipses the claustrophobic hyper-literary world where most poets reside. There is a strong chance that even the jockiest Vermont highschooler would be able to identify his image and maybe even recite a line or two: “Good Fences Make Good Neighbors...” He is, after all, our small state’s claim on culture... President Kennedy gave a speech in his honor the year of his death. But what do we know of the person? What is behind the scruffy, hard-edged yet avuncular, knowing, old man?

A.M. Dolan’s answers that question in “Robert Frost: This Verse Business”. This is a succinct 75 minute monologue, performed by Gordon Clapp. The playwright could have no better vehicle to embody the old Vermonter that this seasoned stage performer.  The direction and set design were also first rate.  All the elements combined to deliver the presence of the poet.  Dolan’s challenge is to include enough of the poet’s work in conjunction with the right amount of biographical detail. If he tilts far in one direction it would seem a pedantic exercise in facts; the other extreme would be merely a spoken word recitation. Dolan strikes the balance: we hear the written work as well as personal quips and stories.  The play opens in the latter part of the poets life with him at the lectern addressing “his public”.  The playwright cleverly has Mr. Frost unable to see his notes due to the harsh lightning.  This is inspired by a famous incident in which the poet was unable to physically read the poem he created for President Kennedy’s inauguration due to the harsh glare of the sunlight. He banters back and forth with an unseen presence that is guiding the event.  His requests for less light are met with inaction. Frost never misses a beat and continues on with his ‘business’ and suddenly, apropos of nothing, the lights are adjusted.  This small exchange is a physical illustration of the poet’s belief in the ability to improvise in the face of God’s unexplainable actions. The poet himself might believe I’m reading too much into the moment.  He scoffs at all the college profs and over-eager truth-seekers who delve too deeply into his simply metaphors. But the playwright has a larger design as does Mr. Frost. His poems have a simple clarity which is often met with derision by the experts who are skeptical that the general public would have any notions of “good poetry”.  Many ‘sophisticated’ academics look upon Frost as merely a showman; the way scientists viewed the television astronomer Carl Sagan. The approachability of his work somehow gives way to the notion of being pedestrian. I would paraphrase a moment in the play in which Frost is asked by a college professor questions the plausibility of the horse in “Stopping by Woods” ringing his bells “to ask if there is some mistake”. Can animals have the capacity to ask good questions? Frost turns the query over to a seasoned farmer in the assembly who is reported to have said “sometimes better than college professors”. Frost has the healthy American skepticism of authority, especially the kind dressed up with the moniker of “expert”.

Gordon Clapp’s performance rises above being mere mimicry.  He looks, sounds and moves as the elder frost (at least judging by archive footage and recordings) but to really be the man himself a performer must mix what is inside his own being.  It’s paradoxical that in order to fully inhabit someone else one must bring themselves into the picture. There is no clue as to the Mr. Clapp’s off stage personality, but what is being experienced on the boards is more than simply hitting the right notes. Mr. Frost was there in Mr. Clapp and vice versa. This was especially true during the sequence in which he recites the blank verse poem, “Death of a Hired Man”. As someone who has run farms I have met many a “Silas” - the subject of Mr. Frost’s harrowing portrait.  This farm hand is a broken man who deserves no favor; but does.  There is nothing logical about the wife’s sympathy as Silas is, by any definition, a wayward narcissist. But it is in the illogic of finding reason to be kind where we find our humanity. One can’t help but wonder if Mr. Frost’s own passion for the curmudgeon underdog had something to do with his own personal fortunate misfortune. This is touched on during the play with opaque references to pre-deceased children, one by suicide. Mr. Dolan strikes this minor chords in passing... making them all the more haunting.  It prompted me to do some digging to confirm what I had suspected: not only was Frost and his spouse plagued with depression; but as a young man he had to commit his sister to a mental hospital where she perished soon after. His grandfather bought him a farm and supported him financially in the beginning. But the real good fortune was his ability to focus on his work and establish his mark on the world by winning a Pulitzer prize at age 50 in 1924. He lived another four decades.... but one wonders if playing the grand old man was more burden than relief.

My father was a college student in the late 1950s and had the honor of escorting Mr. Frost around the campus before one of the command performances.  By that point everyone wanted to see him as there might not be another opportunity given his age. Frost asked my father to go to the college library and check out a book of his poems as he had forgotten his own. The eager young student knocked on the hotel room door and presented “The Complete Poems of Robert Frost”. The elder poet looked at my father and said “I guess if I write another poem I’ll have to do it on the back of this book”.  This was the man Mr. Clapp became at the Lost Nation production: self-deprecating star of the show. He held the audience in rapture with “I’m going to show you how I write a poem”. This was followed by him on the front porch of his cabin clutching pen to paper while sitting in a chair. He held that pose and all the audience with him for what seemed an eternity; only to say: “sometimes it takes time.”  The cabin appears in the closing third of the play and gives rise to soul bearing.... from a man who has skepticism of soul bearers.  In real life an incident occurred in the actual building a couple of years back.  Some highschoolers had a illegal kegger and trashed the place. Being Vermont, the penance was to have a noted Middlebury Professor give them a lecture about the man and his work in order that they realize the gravity of their crime. I felt a cackle from Frost’s grave when I heard the ‘punishment’. Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure the old man would have approved.  The professor chose the poem “Out, out” which tells the story of a young man who cuts off his hand with a chainsaw and bled to death. It is not one of Frost’s major works and not featured in the play. It no doubt captured the imagination of  the captive boys who know the dangers of chainsaws... or at least chainsaws. The closing line is revealing in a way that one could only know from having knowledge of the world’s steely nature:

...................................And they, since they
Were not the one dead, turned to their affairs


No doubt it was lost on the classroom prisoners, who were probably planning another party. Frost would have approved. He might not have shown... but he would have wanted to be invited. He’d grown up in the city and personally never partook in the rural social isolation of many of his solitary creations.

Mr. Dolan has a very clever title to this work: “Robert Frost: This Verse Business”.  It is a quote from the script. One takes the word ‘business’ to mean, ‘business’ in the sense of ‘giving them the business’; or poetry is Frost’s ‘shtick’. But in a broader sense ‘business’ can also mean, vocation. The play is peppered with Frost reflecting on the art of forming a poem. He has an aside where he states “Free verse is like playing tennis without a net”. He derides other poets for being too lax in their structure.  One senses the craftsman, not the artist. In other words Frost seemed to imagine himself as a glass-blower, blacksmith or barrel maker. There is a distinctly tradesman-like kinship he shares with his inspirations. Once again Frost was personally more urban and urbane and never had to fear the result of pecuniary burden of losing a crop.  Here is an excerpt from his NY Times obituary which chronicles his career:

Strangely enough, Frost spent 20 years writing his verses on stone walls and brown earth, blue butterflies and tall, slim trees without winning any recognition in America. When he sent them to The Atlantic Monthly they were returned with this note:
"We regret that The Atlantic has no place for your vigorous verse."
It was not until "A Boy's Will" was published in England and Ezra Pound publicized it that Robert Frost was recognized as the indigenous American poet that he was.
-NY Times, Jan. 30, 1963


Tradesman don’t wait two decades to see if something works... that’s the realm of college men... in fact Frost attended two Ivy League schools but never graduated.  He met Ezra Pound while briefly living outside of London... once again not exactly what one would expect from a homespun frugal Yankee... but he wasn’t... he was actually born in San Francisco before being brought East after his father’s death. Mr. Clapp captures this odd contradiction but Mr. Dolan shaded the duality.  My only note on this very fine production would be to witness the disappearance of the beautiful facade that appears after the ‘lecture’ segment. In other words we see Frost sitting on that porch ‘playing’ the rustic. But I feel it would have been more appropriate if the New England cabin facade literally vanished at the end of the play: Frost in a Godot-like emptiness. He could look at the audience and visually communicate his disdain for people who think they have answers.  He might even recite the epitaph which he took from his poem, “The Lesson for Today”. This work imagines a dialogue with failed poets/teachers of the past. Here are the closing lines:

And were an epitaph to be my story
I’d have a short one ready for my own.
I would have written of me on my stone:
I had a lover’s quarrel with the world.


He was good to his word. That last line is on his tombstone in Bennington. That’s what I took away from watching the hardscrabble romantic... behind the tweed jackets, the adoring fans, the cultural posing, the family grief, the not so simple rustic simplicity... was a lover.





Thursday, September 19, 2013

Lee Daniels' The Butler (2013)

The Black Woman’s Burden

In the interest of full disclosure: epic bio-pics rank with movie adaptations of musical comedies as my least favorite film experience. (see my review of Spike Lee’s “X”: http://thebettertruth.blogspot.com/search?q=%22x%22 ).  “Lee Daniels' The Butler” is a new mainstream feature based on the biography of Eugene Allen, an African American man, who rose from Southern Cotton fields to serve as a key member of the White House staff for decades.  Perhaps “mainstream” is not accurate in that the Hollywood suits never would have bet millions on such a project capturing America’s transition from the Jim Crow era through the civil rights struggle and beyond. Note the competition at the theater I attended: “We’re the Millers” (a Jennifer Aniston comedy with the premise of a stripper traveling to Mexico, incognito as a soccer mom, for a drug deal), “Disney Planes” (animated children’s feature staring anthropomorphic airplanes ), “One Direction: this is Us” (documentary about the pop group featured in 2 and 3D), “The World’s End” (beer drinkers face zombies) and “Elysium” (Matt Damon in future apocalyptic thriller).  The folks at Fox saw this last film as a socialist parable about the evils of our current immigration policy... others view it as simply a slick sci-fi movie. Needless to say one can safely assume that even if this film had a political agenda - it wasn’t going to get funded without a muscle bound, leather clad Damon dancing around pyrotechnical special effects.  It is doubtful that any 11 year old boy (who seem to be the target audience) left the theater with a passion for the plight of illegals or resentment about the class divide. “The Butler” is a no holes bared view of American’s cruel treatment of its black citizens in modern times. It is an overt expose of the dark side of ‘one nation indivisible with liberty and justice for all’.  One can feel the studio executives grabbing the antacid tablets at the early meetings.  I would have loved to have seen a video of one of them turning down Oprah Winfrey. I imagine the dialogue: “It’s a really good script... ah really important BUT....” cue the special effects for Ms. Winfrey’s reaction. 

Oprah is a force of nature in the entertainment business and has shown the willingness to back projects based her personal belief that something is ‘important’.. In fact she has created an industry based on her own taste which has upended television, film and book publishing. Not bad for a woman born to a single black teenage mother who worked as a domestic in Kosciusko Mississippi. One can see that she would be drawn to the story of a man born in the grip of Southern oppression who, working as a domestic, rises to a position where he is on a first name basis with the leaders of the ‘free’ world.  Lee Daniels, a Winfrey protege, is a daring African American journeyman film producer. In 2009 Winfrey put her power behind “Precious”. Mr. Daniels, a former nursing agency entrepreneur, created a film about a morbidly obese, sexually abused illiterate African American teenager. Once again it is easy to understand Ms. Winfrey’s attraction to the plot given her own Dickensian childhood of poverty and abuse.  The film entered the Sundance Festival without a major distributor and finished the year with a multi-million dollar box office gross and a number of Academy Award nominations including Best Picture. It won in the best supporting actress category. None of this would have happened except for Winfrey’s stamp of approval. Not surprisingly “Lee Daniel’s The Butler”  had poor financial prospects given the serious content. In the end - the film was #1 at the box office for 3 weeks and has grossed nearly $100 million.  Note: the budget was around $30 million. Once again... it is Oprah’s world and we just live in it.

Mr. Daniels, as director, is faced with the daunting task of balancing the vast historical story with the relatively small world of the butler.  In 1979 NBC did a television mini-series called “Backstairs at the White House” which chronicled the relations between the Presidents and the domestic staff for a period of 60 years as told from the POV of an African American mother and daughter.  It’s strange that Mr. Daniels failed to give a theatrical nod to the real life Lillian Rodgers Parks whose mother started working as a housemaid in the Taft administration. Parks. who was a seamstress, retired during the Eisenhower administration - the same time the Mr. Daniels character assumed his responsibilities. Perhaps he felt the ‘originality’ of his project was sacrosanct? “Backstairs” was interesting in terms of the historical gossip but the domestics’ domestic challenges were less captivating.  “The Butler” repeats this unfortunate dramatic lull.  Despite Winfrey’s strong appeal as a performer her battles with the bottle and men failed to compete with the Butler interacting with Jack Kennedy during Civil Right mayhem or Nixon during Watergate.

The second major artistic challenge is integrating the history with the arc of the story. Given the fact that the film breaks the two hour mark it is not surprising that this exercise had hits and misses. One must remember this is popular drama for a mass audience rather than detailed scholarly study. Daniels hits all the big moments and the big characters hit their big marks. Daniels has the butler’s son turn into a Zelig-like character who goes from the Freedom Marchers’s daring struggle to the Black Panthers radical excess to anti-apartheid acceptable righteousness while the butler himself struggles with intergenerational torment of having survived Jim Crow. It’s all, well, as one would except. Kennedy is charming. Nixon is creepy. Johnson is vulgar. The butler is appropriately glad/mad/ happy/ sad. Forest Whitaker  has the ability summon vast currents of emotional wattage. I felt my TV set dimming from sheer lack of current during his guest appearance on the TV show “the Shield”. I was nervous about him being cast in this type of drama as his tears and sweat might drench the first few rows of the theater. Ironically he kept it in check - in his case the result is a good heartfelt performance.  Ditto for Winfrey. Although she failed in her battle with history; it was a valiant effort. Daniels’ historical re-enactments create one sharp note amidst the gushing music and gooey cinematography: the portrayal of Ronald Reagan. Given the director’s penchant for simplicity this segment was the unintentional highlight of the film.

Ronald Reagan’s son, Michael, wrote a rebuke to what he saw as a portrait of his father as a racist. Here is the closing paragraph of his Op-Ed entitled “Butler from Another Planet:

Despite what Hollywood’s liberal hacks believe, my father didn’t see people in colors. He saw them as individual Americans. If the liberals in Hollywood -- and Washington -- ever start looking at people the way he did, the country will be a lot better off.

The film itself is extremely generous about Reagan and his relationship with the butler which stood in stark contrast with the President’s support of the racist South African regime. Michael Reagan does not refute the history but instead says the Gipper was acting within the context of Cold War politics not animosity towards blacks. He counters that Reagan had a history of having black friends and standing up for African Americans. The film SUPPORTS the idea that the President was personally NOT a racist.  Reagan trusted the butler to dole out cash to constituents while hiding this from the First Lady and his staff.  The confidence was mutual: the butler trusted him to lift the decades long internal White House wage discrimination against the black staff. In fact Jimmy Carter, the left leaning Democrat, is omitted from the film suggesting that the butler failed to trust him to overturn the internal pay disparity. Interesting question to know if in real life, President Carter, a person who was such a control freak he personally approved who played on the White House tennis court, failed to overturn this longstanding injustice. President Reagan,  according to the film, was affable and righteous in regards to his personal associations with African Americans. His son, however, doth protest to much. The historical record shows failings far beyond the South Africa policy. Reagan was AGAINST the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and his skittishness regarding racial equality carried over into his later career. His first public speech after receiving the Republican Presidential nomination in 1980 was in Philadelphia Mississippi, the town famous for the murder of three civil rights workers during the freedom march. He chose the topic of  “States Rights” saying he would “restore to states and local governments the power that properly belongs to them”. Given this it was not a surprise that the KKK endorsed Reagan for President. The HISTORICAL record clearly shows him capitalizing on white resentment for political gain. Perhaps what upset Michael Reagan was the strange reaction the butler himself had to Nancy Reagan’s invitation to a state dinner as a guest rather than a employee.

The critic Walter Benjamin said that kitsch art "offers instantaneous emotional gratification without intellectual effort, without the requirement of distance, without sublimation".  The Reagan sequence is one of the few moments which require the film audience to dig out the emotional inner life of the characters.  There is nothing in the preceding hour and a half to prepare the audience for the butler’s queasiness at being perceived as the show negro at the White House state dinner. In fact the previous encounters with President and Mrs. Reagan seem genuine and cordial.  Why was the butler offended? It is especially odd given he had just successfully overturned decades of entrenched pay-scale racism within the White House. The First Lady refers to this victory and commends him on his leadership. In the end the butler resigns, ostensibly due to Reagan’s stand on South Africa. The President himself is genuinely saddened and confesses possibly being wrong on civil rights and South Africa - but he never changes his policies. At this point the characters are wrestling with demons that seem to savage the kitsch auto-pilot sensibility of the most of the drama. This conflict has shades of love and hate that stand in stark contrast to the parade of pure representatives of good and evil.   This film needed more of that subtly. It was a jarring moment which gave life to a somnolent storyline; perhaps this is what triggered Reagan’s son to pen the fierce op ed. There were a few other missed opportunities for character introspection. The decision for the butler to leave his mute, mentally ill, sexually abused mother was blurred over in voice over. Ditto for the relationship between himself and the old white female house manager who saved him from the field.  In a monologue he insists that she would miss him dearly although she never showed it.  Why? This is the heart of the story. The friction between good people participating in morally bankrupt actions that hurt those they supposedly love. It is a challenge to paint this portrait using one dimensional characters who rarely let down their guard to show... inner turmoil? denial? justification?... nothing at all?

It is a tall order to wish that this film would plumb the soul of the characters caught up in the struggle for African American enfranchisement.  Perhaps it is an unfair expectation as the creators are illustrating broad stokes of history in palatable easy to digest narratives. Winfrey and Daniels see themselves as delivering a synthesis of grand themes to an audience that has little or no knowledge of the past. This estimation of ignorance might seem harsh until you consider that numerous news outlets have conducted studies which reveal that nearly one third of Americans would fail the civics section of the test given to new immigrants. Once again this trend can only worsen as scores of students abandon History and other humanities subjects in favor of business studies due to the escalation in the price of tuition. In this new harsh economic shrinking pie reality, Winfrey and Daniels are entrepreneurs filling a need. Don’t bother with the nitty gritty - just the outline.  Why become bogged down in MLK’s radical economic views or the Black Panther’s misogyny or Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan’s race politics....  Their product eschews unrelenting negativity and bothersome complications.  Ironically they are pushing the most overreaching, and perhaps pernicious of American values: blind optimism.

Gore Vidal was an author who shared Daniels and Winfrey’s ‘outsider’ status in the traditional halls of power. Although he was to the manor born, he wrote openly about homosexuality in the late 1940s and became a fierce critic of his fellow Brahim.  His historical novels set in 19th century attempt to ‘explain’ the past to the masses he feels are duped by entrenched power.  Vidal quipped : “Half of the American people have never read a newspaper. Half never voted for President. One hopes it is the same half.” No doubt Winfrey and Daniels have the same sense of righteousness.  In their case, however, they are firmly living the American dream.  A ‘happy ending’ is vital to their world view.  It is doubtful that Winfrey or Daniels would ever back a film about such historical events as the 1917 Houston insurrection or the 1921 Tulsa race riots. In both cases the good, law abiding black citizens were crushed under the harsh unforgiving stone wheel of Jim Crow.  The election of the first African American President was vital to the success of this film. The closing sequence features the retired butler being led the oval office by a fawning newly appointed African American chief of White House Operations. It was said that President Obama was asked to actually participate in this film.  Perhaps his advisers recalled the last time a main stream American ‘serious’ bio-pic attempted profundity with a cameo by a real live historical figure: Nelson Mandela’s appearance in Spike Lee’s “X”.  Don’t remember? Neither does anyone else.  The point is that, despite the seeming critique of ‘the system’ - “The Butler” is a parable about the possibility of progressive change in America.

Both Daniels, a black homosexual, and Winfrey, an African American woman, were born into worlds that gave no voice to their respective groups. Both have good reason to applaud America’s bounty. There is, however,  an odd contradiction in being a cheerleader for a system that, statistically, is unkind to so many of your constituents. Perhaps a more appropriate closing for this film would have been the addition of a scene in which the distinguished Butler, who has just met the President, is unable to hail a taxi cab because of his race. The struggles continues and the majority will never see the promise land of equal opportunity. Here is a sobering fact: African Americans make up 13% of the general population and account for 43% of the people in American prisons.  Once again the American dream exists. It is doubtful someone of Ms. Winfrey’s race and class would have been able to achieve the heights of fame of power in any other country. But even the broad strokes of history should be tempered by the ugly reality that class mobility in the United States fails to match rhetoric of our national land of opportunity. The NY Times in 2012 writes that social mobility is greater in Canada and Europe than the land of the free and the brave. (http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/05/us/harder-for-americans-to-rise-from-lower-rungs.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 ) It is important not to overlook the gains made. Women of my grandmother’s generation were born legally disenfranchised from voting. I was born at a time when African American’s were de jure second class citizens. Winfrey and Daniels are correct in celebrating a William Cullen Bryant quote spoken by Dr. King: “Truth crushed to earth will rise again”. But the key is, what truth? It is equally important to  echoed a sentiment spoken by Gore Vidal:

“The genius of our ruling class is that it has kept a majority of the people from ever questioning the inequity of a system where most people drudge along paying heavy taxes for which they get nothing in return.”

Vidal overstates the case and there is nothing wrong with entrepreneurs of any stripe selling historical ‘bon bons’.  It is troubling, however, that there is such little illumination of the economic divide.  One forgets that Dr. King was in the midst of organizing a massive rally pointing out economic injustice when he was assassinated. It would be a tough issue to raise for someone who purchases handbags that equal the downpayment on most homes. Once again expecting Oprah to tackle serious social issues is the equivalent of wanting a Hallmark birthday card to read: another year closer to death.  Certainly a factual statement... but probably not a money maker for the greeting card giant. She is a businesswoman; an entrepreneurial juggernaut, PERIOD. Mr. Daniels is a first rate commercial director, PERIOD. Buying into the premise that they are social activists, is akin to believing one will change the world by buying Ben and Jerry’s ice cream.  It is sophomoric to expect our good natured moguls to be superhero activists. Oprah’s life is a testament what is good in American, as is Mr. Daniels; but that should never be confused with greatness... either artistically or morally. It’s too bad Oprah didn’t take a shine to Matt Damon’s “Elysium”... she might have given gravitas to all the fireworks. The 11 year old might have started to wonder about more than explosions.... what if he left the theater and asked his parents: “how come our house isn’t as nice as their house” - now that would be revolutionary.

Saturday, September 07, 2013

100 Year Anniversary of the Plainfield Vermont Volunteer Fire Department


The Plainfield Volunteer Fire Department was formed the same year a band of Vermont Civil War Veterans had gathered to mark the 50th anniversary of their struggle at the Battle of Gettysburg. This year, a century later, Vermont Veterans organized a parade to mark the 50 year anniversary of the Vietnam war.  Things change... but the important things remain.  The people who founded this organization probably never saw an engine driven firetruck - they were invented only 6 years earlier -  but they would be familiar with the real part of being a volunteer. Being called away from the office, farm or quarry at an odd hour to risk one’s life to help save a random neighbor for no reason that anyone from ‘away’ would understand.  Robert Frost said “Good Fences make good neighbors”.  People often quote this line to underscore our individualism which is as bountiful as all those granite boulders that pop out from the dark brown cow pastures. We are set in our ways and our ways are not our neighbors. Back to Mr. Frost’s poem: “He is all pine and I am apple orchard”.  What people who live ‘away’ don’t understand is that the neighbors in the poem re-build the wall TOGETHER - every year. They do it even though one of the neighbors thinks the other is crazy and there is absolutely no logical need for the wall as neither has livestock and the boundary is clearly marked by a change in tree variety. One keeps asking questions. They other keeps answering by not answering and yet.... they BOTH keep re-building the wall every year.

I have little doubt that if the original fire brigade was looking around at us they’d be asking some serious questions: what is a traffic light? why do you spend so much time on those things you call radios? why are those things you call firetrucks ‘yellow’?  But when the siren rings everyone would fall inline.  The men of 1913 would join with the people of 2013 and they go and put out a fire. They’d be uneasy on the truck; which would seem to move as a rocket compared to their horse drawn rig. They would not be familiar with working with women in this capacity..... but in the end they would all join in the rescue. The important things remain true. Whether pine or orchard, EVERYONE knows: good fences make good neighbors and good volunteers make a good town.

Organized firemen have been around since the days of ancient Rome. Volunteer Fire Departments have been in the United States since the beginning. President George Washington was a volunteer fireman. This gives me hope that the institution will survive in some form for the bicentennial in 2113.  Perhaps a young child who is here with us today will be an honored guest at that celebration. I’m sure there will be questions. I can imagine the man who wears the white helmet at that time showing this person an image of Chief Martin in a multi-colored Plainfield Volunteer Fire Department shirt. The question would be ‘what is the significance of the pattern on the clothing?’. The person would respond: "it’s a Tie-dyed T-shirt. The hippies used to wear them." And the current Chief would say: "what is a ‘hippie’? and why was Chief Martin one of them?"  At the same time the Old Home day parade would be hovering slowly down a palm tree lined Route 2 in the modern flying vehicles.  They would pass the Gary Graves Town Hall Building; which would be famous at that time for having the driest basement of any structure in Vermont. At that point the parade route would pass through the dangerous intersection down into Plainfield  Village- the town would still be trying to get funds from AOT for repairs and the Selectboard would still be saying ‘it’s a few years away’.  A young child will point at the Plainfield  Volunteer Fire Department Vehicle and ask her mother. “How come our town has a yellow one and all the other ones are red?”  The mother will answer in a very clear voice: “Plainfield is not plain. Never has been. Never will be.”  The important things remain true.



Monday, September 02, 2013

Blue Jasmine (2013)

Woody Allen, Working Man

Woody Allen has written and directed a feature film every year since 1977 and he is on schedule to complete another project in 2014. This is AFTER a two decades of establishing himself as a stand up comic and show business writer.  It is astounding that the super-star auteur writer/director of my youth in the 1970s would still  be producing work. What is even more extraordinary is his latest films have been commercially and critically the most successful of his career. “Midnight in Paris”, “Vicky Christina Barcelona” and “Match Point” were all made in the last decade and have certainly equaled or excelled the inflation adjusted box office for such Allen classics as:  “Annie Hall”, “Manhattan” and “Hannah and her Sisters”.  The word ‘genius’, which was commonly associated with Mr. Allen in his prime, has once again been resurrected. Proof is in the pudding - the latest feature “Blue Jasmine” - has the premiere performers of the moment lining up to work for scale on this project: Cate Blanchett, Alec Baldwin,  Louie C.K have all joined to have their names appear in alphabetical order in Woody’s trademark Windsor-EF-Elongated font with soft jazz music playing in the background. Decade after decade, serious talent wants to join the club.  Mr. Allen deserves high praise for his business acumen in creating an American art-house brand.  He has a kindred spirit in another Bronx born entrepreneur. Those people on the upper east side of Manhattan might not take notice of Ralph Lipschitz and Allan Konigsberg ... but they proudly wear Ralph Lauren and would do anything to be in a Woody Allen movie. Let the naysayers carp about Lauren’s lack of originality or Allen’s unevenness as a writer/director.  These men view the world through the eyes of their immigrant families and have a different ‘bottom line’. Ralph Lauren classic car collection has been featured in the Musee des Arts Decoratifs in Paris. Woody Allen used to park his chauffeur driven cream-colored Rolls Royce in front of Elaine’s restaurant. What kind of cars do the critics’ drive?

“Blue Jasmine” is about the familial devastation wrought by a con-man; who has affairs and simultaneously destroys the financial stability of his friends, family and business associates.  The cruel aftermath of marital deception coupled with heinous crimes has been visited by Mr. Allen on a few occasions. “Crimes and Misdemeanors” has a doctor killing his lover to safeguard his marriage. “Matchpoint” reprises this scenario.  In both cases the men remain relatively unscathed by their treachery. “Blue Jasmine” has a far bleaker outcome.  In this case, however, it is told from the woman’s POV.  The wrongdoer faces justice but the spouse seems to suffer a worse fate. Ironically ‘loyalty’ trumps dishonesty. In other words the despicable actions of the Bernard Madoff trickster, played effectively by Alec Baldwin, seem less of a problem then Cate Blanchett’s failure to stand by her man. Her performance is outstanding.  She brings a heartfelt depth to the character which should be attributed to her gifts as a performer; rather than Allen’s work as a writer/director. She created a silk purse from a ponderous, narcissistic cow’s ear full of  dialogue.  One of the challenge's in Allen’s films is a lack of gravitas.  This is understandable in that his roots are in slap-stick comedy rather than drama.  Allen in at his best in mad-cap social satire: “Play it Again Sam”, “Sleeper”, “Everything You Wanted to Know About Sex”.  His work takes on an unappealing sophomoric angst when he wades into the deeper end of the pool: “Interiors”, “Husband and Wives”, “Stardust Memories”... Unfortunately he is most personally revealing in these moments. “Husband and Wives” was shot while he was still married to his co-star Mia Farrow. Unfortunately it was released during the tumultuous divorce where it was revealed he had left his wife for his step daughter. The Allen character in the film ends up embracing a bachelor life. He feels he has hurt enough people with his failed attempts at intimacy. In real life Allen married his step-daughter permanently estranging himself from Farrow and their biological child. “Stardust Memories”, which Allen considers his best work, features a filmmaker who laments that fans prefer his “earlier, funnier movies”.  Perhaps it is because the protagonists, who bear a striking resemblance to their creator, fail to be sympathetic.  The lovable onscreen persona Allen delivers in his early work, a nebbish, overly-intellectual, clumsy, insecure mensch/shlemiel, gives way to something closer to Sammy Glick - the rags to riches sociopath in Bud Shulberg’s “What Makes Sammy Run”.  The ‘real-life’ Allen is a multi-lingual former high school athletic star who, in addition to being a playwright and best selling author, is a professional musician. He was out-earning his parents in his early teens writing comedy.  There is nothing wrong with being ambitious and talented but the tenor of his work betrays a meanness. There are no real good guys in Woody Allen films... just head cases, villains and scores of set-piece clowns.  The drift away from ‘slapstick’ has brought his dour world-view into sharper focus. The characters are fleeting in their griefs and triumphs. One always remembers the ‘gags’ or one-liners in Allen films... but never the characters - save the ever-changing Mr. Allen himself. Now that he has retired from onscreen appearances his work has become a pastiche of well-known performers acting out clever set-piece dramas. Nothing wrong with that... we all enjoy parking our brains at the door while we much away on the popcorn.... but it would be wise to raise our ‘genius’ bar for the real McCoy. 

“Blue Jasmine” is a callow view of contemporary class friction.  Ironically Allen, who knows both worlds intimately, fails to deliver. There is a forced quality to his portraits which hints that he stopped noticing people, blue or white collar, decades ago. The stilted exposition combined with laughable plot points renders the whole enterprise stillborn.  Allen, who studied under famed writing teacher Lajos Egri, might want to dust off a copy of his “The Art of Dramatic Writing”... specifically the section addressing ‘coincidences’. Are we really supposed to believe that the protagonist runs into her nemesis at the exact moment her lover is purchasing an engagement ring? And to add insult to injury: the clever fiancee, who is an upperclass worldly diplomat, never performed a basic google-search of the new love of his life?  And to add insult to injury squared - the nemesis reveals a long lost relative who is a short commute from where she is standing? There are two simple words for this: bad writing.   Once again the craft and talent give the veneer of quality.   The references, accents and accoutrements are all spot on... but the center does not hold.   It is interesting to contrast “Blue Jasmine” with the television season of “Damages” which re-creates the Madoff mayhem.  Glenn Close’s portrayal of an ambitious prosector is an interesting parallel to Cate Blachett. These women are first rate actresses at the top of their game and deliver unforgettable performances. The difference is that Close’s work integrates with the overall storyline and has meaningful impact on one’s views of Madoff’s real-life actions.  Blachett merely gives an unforgettable performance. Once again it is worth twice the price of admission to see her tackle this part - but it has nothing to do with the high stakes morality of conning your closest loved ones and sending them into financial ruin. “Damages” delivers the damage. “Blue Jasmine” riffs on the major chords but fails to deliver a nuanced solo. The result is as forgettable as running water. Once again there are some marvelous performances Of note: Andrew Dice Clay resurrects himself from the doldrums of self-induced career suicide and  constructs a meaningful rendering of a little man caught in a rich man’s world.  Unfortunately Allen fails to possess the writing ability to raise this person from the shoals of caricature.... a problem that has plagued his ‘serious’ work for many decades. It all stems from Allen’s dread of real emotional connection and revelation.

Woody Allen’s Wikipedia bio, which omits any mention of his messy divorce and high profile court fight with his long-time producers, has a brief line about Allen’s father: Martin Konigsberg. They describe him as a “jewelry engraver and a waiter.”  There is another profession the elder Konigsberg had which is not listed. During the heyday of Allen’s work in the late 70s and early 80s his father was a messenger in Allen’s production office.  It is hard to understand this arrangement as one might think Allen might prefer to buy the old man a small house in Boca Raton rather than face him EVERY DAY at work.  It is difficult to know the inter-personal dynamics - certainly Woody isn’t blabbing.  But it sheds light on a die-hard work ethic. Certainly Mr. Konigsberg felt the need to show up for the job and earn his keep. Having been born in 1900 he was in his late 70s early 80s at the time and no doubt he might have found an easier way of passing the time. It is interesting to pair this ‘need to work’ with Allen’s own obsessive dedication to his career. Throughout all the personal turmoil he never has gone a year without having some substantial project to show for it. One might say the process has overtaken his need to dig in the emotional weeds of self-examination. Humor has always been a trusted friend from the demons of personal-introspection. Unfortunately dramatic work requires the personal risk of ‘putting yourself on the line’.  “Blue Jasmine” has an important moment centered around a child formally rejecting a parent.  It is, despite strong performances, merely another note in the clumsy storyline. Strange to think Allen himself has faced this torment and yet there is nothing of ‘him’ in this writing - just platitudes and plot points. But perhaps the expectation that Allen would live up to his ‘press’ really misses the point. Mr. Konigsberg, who died a centenarian, might be able to say a thing or two about people the press dub as ‘geniuses’.  He strikes me as someone who wasn’t interested in hype - life is about the bottom line. I think that spirit is passed down in his son.  The Wikipedia page lists scores of accolades - including a life sized bronze sculpture of himself erected in a town in Spain. Allen is smart enough to know he is more Salieri than Mozart but worrying about that sort of truth is reserved for private school kids. He built his business. He  sells stuff that people like and playing ‘genius’ is part of the schtick.  They want to complain - they can come to him. He’s not collecting Oscars or giving seminars or wasting time on talk shows. I imagine a film reviewer asking him, point blank: why don’t you try harder? Why not make a real film about betrayal instead of showcasing vain, shallow representations of rich and poor? The nebbish/kooky artist would vanish and he’d be face to face with Sammy Glick who would stare deep into their eyes: “Who the f#%* are you? What have you directed lately? How much money did you earn last year?”... then after a pause.... “What do you drive?”..... Then after an even longer pause  “You’re not getting tickets for a screening of the next one... you’re paying retail like everyone else”. 

Woody is laughing all the way to the bank.... of course it’s not really about the money... that’s only valuable in that it’s proof of his standing with the ruling class. But there is a sense that he’s playing everyone for what it’s worth.  He’s funny but I sense an emptiness when he stops telling jokes. I am in the vast minority. If Woody’s dad’s age is any indicator of the director’s longevity:  there will scores of more films, the hottest talent will be lining up to be in them and people in the know will be lining up to see them. As the song goes, “It’s nice work if you can get it.” I wonder, is this a comedy?... or something else.

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Heartbreak House (2013 Unadilla Theater, VT)

Heartfelt House

I went to see a production of “Heartbreak House” in a rural theater in the middle of the Vermont countryside.  Topical social satire rarely stands the test of time. George Bernard Shaw’s 90 year old indictment of the English ruling class surprises in that it still has currency. Shaw captured the dissonance of a mannered old world slipping into the tumult of a ruling class aristocracy without manners and boundaries.   Shaw’s original audience, suffering the new horror of WW I’s mechanized warfare, would have recognized the young ingenue’s metamorphosis into a callus operator.  No doubt even the most priggish blue-blood must have felt the blinders slipping away into a brave new world.  Henry James and Edith Wharton spent entire tombs in which the denouement reveals a woman’s honor has been compromised. Shaw speeds the plow and the young woman is undone, so to speak, half way through the first act. Whereas earlier writers might have had the wounded leading lady crawl into the shadows, Shaw’s heroine charges towards the limelight.  The supporting cast is equally novel in their approach to social grace: all three of the established couples have open relations and the patriarch is married to someone of a different race. In fact  the only character who has a conventional matrimonial union schemes to have his only daughter married off to one of his contemporaries. In fact he makes no bones about the fact that his friend is a scoundrel.  When confronted with the darkness of his actions his answer is simple: my friend has a great deal of money.  Such brazen honesty would have been a ticket out of polite society in the Gilded Age.... but not in the upcoming Jazz age. This post WW I era is similar to our own time in terms of the shift of social norms.  I was born when blacks and women were officially sanctioned second class citizens; homosexuals were criminals, telephone answering machines did not exist and copying machines were a new invention. Someone who was 30 in 1919, when “Heartbreak House” opened, would have grown up witnessing the following ‘new‘ inventions: the electric grid, the telephone and the automobile.  The effects on society were equally dramatic: women, in most Western Democracies, were granted the vote and the ‘Downton Abbey’ set was feeling the ever-present push of the merchant class. In this paradigm shifting moment Shaw had something to say... and it still has resonance for the internet age.

Shaw had an unconventional personal life: born of modest means he married an heiress who shared his passion for socialism and women’s rights.  His wife refused to have sex which led Shaw to have a number of affairs with married women but it is unclear if any of his relationships were consummated. In addition to being a playwright he was an author and a formidable music and theater critic.  “Heartbreak House” was actually written before the war but he held off production until after hostilities had ceased. This was not someone too concerned with offending popular sensibilities so one might attribute the delay to a difficulty in finding a producer.  The original title of the play was ‘A Fantasia in the Russian Manner on English Themes’.  It would have been an mouthful but it does deliver the timbre of the piece: if Oscar Wilde had been touched with Chekov’s sense of irony. The result forces the audience into wry smiles and brief laughter rather than guffaws. The characters are equally repulsive and likable. The challenge for the cast is that there are no real heroes or villains which demands an intense level of focus in order to create the lifeblood of all good theater: empathy. The Unadilla cast did an admirable job of embodying the strange melange of brimstone and treacle. This arts organization operates on shoestring budget and utilizes some non-professional performers.  Even amidst these constraints the result is admirable. It is not easy to mix actors with varying degrees of experience especially in an intricate ensemble production. Kudos to the people on the front lines but it is also important to acknowledge the visionaries behind the scenes.  In a world obsessed with money and liability there exists a maverick with the grit and determination to build two theaters in the middle of nowhere. I have lived in the neighboring town for years and became completely lost in the dense forest occasionally punctuated with open pasture.  It is 5 miles from the nearest paved road. Audience members, even with packed houses, are outnumbered by the sheep and highland cattle in the surrounding fields. No doubt G. B. Shaw would have found a kindred spirit with such pioneers. This was a man who abhorred conventionality and the pursuit of money in equal measure.  His head-strong lack of regard for accepted wisdom has, at times, diminished his legacy. His embrace of Stalin combined with his fondness for eugenics is problematic for the contemporary reader. Nevertheless his fierce advocacy for women’s rights and his unending dedication to helping the underclass, are extraordinary for a man of his time.  Inevitably one must draw comparisons to the other Anglo-Irish playwright/breaker of societal norms: Oscar Wilde. They were two years apart in age.

If there is anyone who seems ‘heroic’ in Heartbreak House it is the old sea-captain. This character embodies Shaw’s own hardscrabble musings.  His harsh truism come with a tinge of  resignation. This isn’t Henry V. This is Richard II with Richard III’s swagger.  It should be noted that author possess the modern sense of irony by saddling his ‘superman’ with a serious drinking problem and the name “Shotover”; in addition he has such blind narcism that he fails to even acknowledge his opponents. Actually the adversaries are created out of whole-cloth with the actual person in front of him transforming into a bemused stand-in.  His daughter is not his daughter - until she is. The singer’s father is always a complete stranger with a similar name. Note that Capt. Shotover, in allegiance to the modern day survivalists, has his dynamite... just in case. He understands the world and knows he has lost... but he isn’t defeated. At this point it is interesting to compare his witticisms with Oscar Wilde’s:

G. B. Shaw: Old men are dangerous: it doesn't matter to them what is going to happen to the world.
-Capt. Shotover, Heartbreak House

Oscar Wilde: Men become old, but they never become good.
 -Duchess of Berwick, “Lady Windermere's Fan”

G. B. Shaw: When our relatives are at home, we have to think of all their good points or it would be impossible to endure them. But when they are away, we console ourselves for their absence by dwelling on their vices.
-Hesione Hushabye, Heartbreak House

Oscar Wilde: Relations are simply a tedious pack of people who haven't got the remotest knowledge of how to live, nor the smallest instinct about when to die.
- Algernon Moncrieff,  The Importance of Being Earnest

In short: Shaw is clever and funny;  Wilde is funny and clever. The difference in their writing reflects the mirror images of the men’s personal habits: Shaw was a teetotaling vegan while Wilde was, well, wild. Shaw died a celebrated figure in the 1950s, six years shy of his 100th birthday. Wilde died broke at the turn of the century after fleeing England due to a sex scandal. Shaw’s rage at the ruling class is studied and pointed. Wilde had a different approach: “if you want to tell people the truth, make them laugh, otherwise they’ll kill you”. Ironically they killed him despite his good humor.  And Shaw survived despite his more direct lines of attack. In the end “Heartbreak House” has resonance but lacks tenderness. The kind of work that comes from someone who can give wonderful lectures on humanity - but never consummates a passionate relationship. Perhaps a better title would have been “Brain-break House”. This is not to say Shaw is cold - he is a keen observer. Unfortunately he failed to be a ‘player’ in manner of Wilde. The latter’s ability to genuinely feel the heartbreak makes for a stronger connection with the audience. Fortunately the players at the Unadilla had strong enough feeling to carry the day. Their hearts were in the right place... it showed. Perhaps they should consider walking on the Wilde-side. 

Sunday, July 21, 2013

Star Trek Into Darkness (2013)

To Professionally Go

Pity the director who must take on a ‘Star Trek’ movie. The suits want ‘box-office’ while Trekkies want a worshipful adherence to an established tradition. J.J. Abrams, the wunderkind scion of a screenwriting family, deferred to the suits - there is a reason it’s called showBUSINESS. The result is coolly professional film.  It won’t please conventioneers or people who know how to speak Kligon... but who really cares about them anyway..... Unfortunately this is exactly what is wrong with ‘Star Trek Into Darkness’.  It manages to be a solid piece of action Sci-Fi filmmaking; but technical prowess was never the thing... at least for those who climbed aboard the maiden voyage in the 1960s.

For the uninitiated : Star Trek began as a TV series in the late 1960s.  The network wanted to cancel the show after the second run. In the end a letter writing campaign by female viewers forced the studio agree to a third (and final) season.  This proved decisive as only shows with 3 years worth of work were syndicated.  It is ironic that women would come to the rescue as the original series has a ‘Mad Men’ misogynistic view of the fairer sex. There are a myriad of episodes where aliens in low cut dresses fall for the sexually insatiable Capt. Kirk.  However this isn’t a show merely about sailors on shore leave. The plots are really  idea driven narratives. This was a show about the wider world, not explosions and special effects. Whereas the husbands might be craving Steve McQueen tearing up the road in “Bullitt”, their spouses were taking in the larger lessons of this groundbreaking sci-fi TV show.  How groundbreaking?  Well the first interracial kiss on prime time television features Kirk and Lt. Uhura locking lips. Yes her outfit was Barbie-ish, but how many African American women were featured as high ranking officers of military/exploration organizations?  Answer: NONE.  We couldn’t even imagine such a thing in 1960s fiction with the exception of Star Trek. This show was special. It has garnered the type of pop culture devotion which borders on being a religious cult.  It’s not just dressing up for Star Trek conventions... Trekkies, metaphorically speaking, put pen to paper - there are thousands of pages of fan fiction dedicated to the original series alone. No doubt JJ knows all this and more.... and he gave a nod to the old guard of fanatical fans: this film touches on the very current topic of military overreach into civil society. The problem is that all this build-up is merely an excuse for the fx crews and pyro-techincal staff to have a field-day. JJ unknowingly seems to illustrate that when it comes to Star Trek - “the plays the thing” and not the phaser.

One of the odd things that ham-strings this film is the choice of Chris Pine as Capt. Kirk.  JJ reprises his coupling of Mr. Pine with Zachary Quinto as Spock to echo the original pairing of William Shatner as the Captain and Leonard Nimoy the first officer. He got it half right. Quinto can shape the taciturn half-vulcan to his own image whereas Pine is locked into mimicking the original item.  He is neither himself or William Shatner but rather himself aping Shatner. Unfortunately the end result is a talented actor play-acting a histrionic icon.  Whereas there was a professional wrestling bravado to Shatner’s sexual swagger,  Pine seems to be faking it.  He hits his marks but somehow it lacks the levity and camp-believability of the primogeniture.  There is also a dearth of chemistry between the new pair.  A fair amount of the original fan fiction focused on the buried eroticism between Kirk and Spock - as if they were a couple. It would be hard to believe anyone would day-dream about the new pair getting together. Without this elusive bond the events fall into fairly predictable set-pieces of victory being snatched from the jaws of defeat at the final moment. This motif was a Star Trek standby but once again it was the characters bonds which held the show together.  In a sense the whole series might be summed up by a moment in one of the original episodes where the pair return to Vulcan.  Spock and Kirk are forced to fight to the death in order to satisfy the sacred local customs. Spock is beamed back to the ship believing he has murdered his friend and captain. It turns out that McCoy has cleverly given a drug to Kirk in order to feign death.  The denouement occurs when Spock sees his beloved ALIVE.  He breaks his cool Vulcan demeanor and exclaims: “JIM!”  The women who wrote those letters to extend the series weren’t interested in explosions, costumes leading to dramatic rescues.  They wanted to see the way Kirk, Spock and McCoy et al... reacted to EACHOTHER.


The opening sequence of “Into Darkness” illustrates the stark contrast with the original.  The film hits the ground running - literally.  Our heroes are incognito drawing the natives away from a volcano that is about to blow in order to safeguard this developing civilization. Meanwhile back in the center of the volcano Mr. Spock is trying to avert a cataclysmic eruption.  It’s about to blow and the Captain must balance the cumbersome regs and saving his friend.  Don’t forget the ‘prime directive’: there can be no interference with the internal development of alien civilizations. In other words the natives aren’t supposed to see you or know you’re there.... what to do?  Well don’t worry it all works out and the planet is saved and our protagonists triumph... except when they get back to headquarters.  Spock, with his usual ‘missing the forest for the trees’ cluelessness, unknowingly betrays his friend.... literally almost costing Kirk his commission for violating the prime directive.  Contrast this with one of the opening episodes in the original series where Spock deliberately violates orders in order to secure a homeland for his friend, a Capt. Pike.  JJ’s script violates the prime directive of Star Trek: Spock is cold, ruthless and non-human - except when it comes to his beloved friends.  In this case the overall give and take between the new pair makes Spock’s error almost believable. In other words Lenard Nimoy would throw himself on his sword for William Shatner; but Zachary Quinto is less concerned with Chris Pine.... and who could blame him.  They do ‘get along’, in professional way - and it all makes sense, in a professional way.... but where is the magic that made this the most successful movie franchise in the history of cinema?

“Into Darkness” zips along at warp speed: the Federation under attack, Vulcans burning for war, spies are amongst  the crew..... Abrams does an admiral job of translating the original ‘Cold War’ dynamic into contemporary political concerns. The original show cast the Federation as a stand in for liberal democracies.  the Klingons and Romulians were the Russians and Chinese.  Our current dynamic sees us chasing enemies from within; hence an evil Federation Admiral who places his judgement above those of the people his is serving.  The script presents a credible story of what happens when we forget our core values. It has solid action sequences and solid performances... and yet.  I guess I wanted to go “where no one has gone before”. Instead I felt a familiar dull coldness of material produced with calculation rather than heart. It is said that Abrams is going to be involved with a ‘Star Wars’ project. A bean counter would lump ‘Star Wars’ and ‘Star Trek’ as similar Sci-Fi outer space narratives.  A real ‘fan’ of either franchise could speak for hours on the difference. The bean-counter would point to the fact that ‘Stark Trek Into Darkness’ has grossed over $400 million worldwide and was the #1 grossing domestic movie on opening weekend.  Abrams ‘Star Wars’ endeavor might prove equally financially rewarding. Unfortunately it will be equally lacking. I can’t explain... you need to ask the women who started the letter writing campaign.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Oblivion (2013)

Apocalypse Now and Then

There is something about end of world dramas that prompts writers to bang the pulpit and throw in some religion with the special effects. “Oblivion”, the latest Tom Cruise apocalyptic sci-fi thriller, is no exception. “The Book of Revelation” reigns large in the American psyche; even thetans aren’t immune. For those not familiar with the good book: it has a happy ending. The good guys win the big fight. “Oblivion” begins with the interesting notion that we won the battle; but lost the earth. Cruise is a commander of a ‘mop up‘ operation where the remaining resources of a doomed earth are being salvaged for a new human colony on one of Jupiter’s moons. You see during the raging conflict, started by invaders from outer space, the earth’s moon was destroyed sending a torrent of earthquakes and planet-spanning tidal waves.   Tom and his wife/partner/work colleague oversea a guard station in which they protect the machines that are sucking up the earth’s remaining water from remnants of the invaders who are still lurking in the scarred remnants of the beloved mother planet. Tom actually does the heavy lifting of repairing the protector drones while wifey talks to headquarters. They live in a Philippe Starck apartment/satellite/airport hub (with see-through pool) which hovers over the clouds.  Am I going to fast? It’s all explained in 10 minutes of voiceover replete with Tom looking serious and wifey appearing busy/anxious.  Narration is usually an escape hatch for directors who are overwhelmed with the story. Even though Joseph Kosinski is the author, the film is no exception. The creative team was shooting for Romans 12:21, “Be not overcome of evil, but overcome evil with good”. Unfortunately the verse that comes to mind is Ecclesiastes 1:9, “There is nothing new under the sun”.

As a certified non-celebrity I share the fantasy that the superstars of our universe have the world at the palm of their hand. Tom Cruise could hire almost anyone to write and direct his projects. Why would he turn to Joseph Kosinski? Well.... he’s smart.  He is an assistant professor in architecture with a degree from Columbia. His venture into filmmaking began by combining his proficiency in 3D modeling with his passion for graphic novels. His work, “Oblivion”, was published by Radical Comics - a cutting edge multi-media studio. This resume answers puzzling questions about two things that stood out from the tedious familiarity: the helicopter/spaceship and the post-modernist apartment.  These two elements were great and seemed to possess something the story, set-design, script all lacked.... a fresh sense of purpose.  In these small objects Kosinki really showed his stuff.  If only the director could channel the energy he spent on those two things to the script, there might have been something to watch.  Otherwise we are bogged down in an endless stream of sci-fi cliches which seemed to permeate the setting as well as the script. Kubrick’s evil ‘HAL’ makes a grand appearance. The ‘Star Wars” death star is reconfigured. The drones seem to have borrowed their look from R2D2. Since “Return of the Planet of the Apes” it has been de rigueur to include the ruins of the Statue of Liberty amongst earth’s debris.  The story itself has the smell of old Star Trek episodes relating to cloning, eco-peril, the dangers of technology..... Kosinski is, no doubt, brilliant but his creative strength seems limited to visual acuity rather than movie based narrative storytelling. I have not viewed the graphic novel but it is VITAL to understand that, whatever its strengths, film is a different medium. Picture books, no matter how dynamic, are NOT motion pictures.

Perhaps the best film created by architect/designers is the short classic “Powers of Ten” by the legendary couple Charles and Ray Eames. (the film can be seen at ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fKBhvDjuy0 ). This is the text which appears on screen after the title itself: A FILM DEALING WITH THE RELATIVE SIZE OF THINGS IN THE UNIVERSE AND THE EFFECT OF ADDING ANOTHER ZERO. This awkwardly phrased summary is in stark contrast to the wonderfully concise and clear ‘narrative’ which explains ‘size’ on a grand scale.  Once again it hints at deficiencies in otherwise gifted designers.  Brevity is lacking in the skill-set. Now imagine if these fine minds had come together to tackles grand issues of religion and philosophy.... One can clearly see that this would lead to “Oblivion”. It is vital that ‘special’ people choose the right material. Ironically the formula is counter-intuitive: the academic firepower of the director should be in inverse proportion to the size of the topic at hand in order to yield the grander statement. Kosinki gift lends itself to exquisite work on a small scale rather than worldly themes of universal import. 

The hero of “Oblivion” exhibits a ‘back to the garden’ desire. It’s the same prelapsarian conflict shown in countless sci-fi epics (e.g. “Avatar”, “Star Trek Insurrection”, “Star Wars”).   It would have been interesting if Kosinki had focused exclusively on this theme. The cumbersome complicated ‘conspiracy’ and clumsy set up, inhibited all hope of bringing the characters to life. In this vein perhaps a re-make of “Silent Running is in order. This 1972 space drama focuses on an astronaut who mutinies against his crew in order to save the last remaining plants. It certainly more interesting than the original “Tron” which the suits decided to revise with Kosinki at the helm.  (I couldn’t bring myself to see his version as I was haunted by the boredom of the original.)  “Oblivion” also brought to mind Danny Boyle’s “Sunshine” - a very interesting, much ignored, space thriller. Boyle had the good sense to devise an exquisitely simple premise in order to focus on what we all really want to see: development of the characters within the movie. “Sunshine” boils down to a small crew manning a ship on a salvation mission to fire a device into the waning sun in order to save earth from freezing. The SIMPLE mission becomes intensely dynamic as the struggles of the various individuals are paramount. Contrast this with the convoluted ‘set up’ of “Oblivion”. Despite the careful ten minute voice over the audience is left scrutinizing the storyline IN ADDITION to the drama. The many ‘reveals’ feel more akin to solving medium difficult crossword puzzles rather than character epiphanies.  There is no room for romance or heroics when the focus is on plotline GPS.

“Oblivion” was the NUMBER ONE box office movie this past weekend.  What is a ‘successful’ film? It brought to mind Cary Grant.  Some people felt he should raise the bar on his choice of material citing his starring in a comedy set on a submarine. He pointed out it garnered him a golden globe nomination. In addition it was within the top five top grossing films that year.  History has proven him correct in that adjusted for inflation this was the most financially successful work of his career. (http://cogerson.hubpages.com/hub/Cary-Grant-Box-Office-Grosses-from-his-best-and-worst-movies)  That same year he made another film which earned less money and failed to earn him any awards.  In hindsight it’s hard to imagine anyone considering “North by Northwest” less ‘successful’ than “Operation Petticoat”.... but this is the problem with merely counting figures and citing accolades.  It is something Tom Cruise should consider as he is at a point in his career which is akin to a second US Presidential term: the legacy is the thing. 

Given the last few outings it is time to re-assess Tom’s script selection process. Kudos to him for making a daring political statement in “Lions for Lambs”; although the result artistically fell short.     ( http://thebettertruth.blogspot.com/2007/11/lions-for-lamb-by-bores-heres-joke-for.html ) He also deserves praise for playing against type in  “Magnolia”, “ Tropic Thunder” and “Rock of Ages”. The “Mission Impossible” franchise can pay the rent, so what are we to make of: “Jack Reacher”, “Knight and Day”, “Valkyrie”.... and now "Oblivion"? Once again from my view in 'little people' oblivion it seems self evident that: a. something is wrong and b. it is fixable. Note to Tom: raise bar on material selection. Don’t be fooled by degrees. Don’t hire a cook to do your gardening. Don’t hire an architect to be a writer/director. Why not give Danny Boyle a call. Whether or not these turkeys hit; it doesn’t do much for your standing. Remember Romans 2:6 : (God) “will repay each person according to what they have done.” You’re audiences don’t want to end up on the submarine in “Operation Petticoat”;  they'd rather be flying North on NorthWest Airlines.

Sunday, April 14, 2013

The Place Beyond the Pines (2012)

Fathers and Sons

The local art-house movie theater was showing a Ryan Gosling picture called ‘The Place Beyond the Pines’. The poster had a blurb from entertainment weekly saying ‘riveting crime drama’. I took the bait. The opening sequence was promising - a steady cam shot of our anti-hero, carnival-attraction, motorcycle-stunt man.... sucking up the sleazy circus milieu while cooly acknowledging the adulation of star-struck teenagers. Within the first 8 minutes there were two references to Scorsese’s films: the entrance to the Copacabana in ‘Goodfellas’ and the introduction of the tattooed De Niro in ‘Cape Fear’. They worked well. No dialogue but the strut and small touches were worth reams of carefully written description .  The audience was going on a ride with someone who knew what they were doing.  The long single-shot gave the feeling of a director, Derek Cianfrance, in sync with a movie star. Gosling and him had worked previously on a dark romance, ‘Blue Valentine‘, which I have not seen.  According to the press he has been making films since he was 13 and became a darling of Sundance with his debut feature in 1998. This movie starts well. The love interest is quickly introduced with some pithy exposition:  He had disappeared. She was disappointed. She now has a man. He’s leaving. He comes back. He finds out a dark secret. Things are building.  So far so good.  Then... well...  To quote Auden, “the center did not hold”... or perhaps more precisely: there was no center to hold.... just a long series of events stretching into the horizon.

After an hour and a half the main storyline came to a climatic finish.  I expected to see ‘the end’ credits, but instead was greeted with a black cue card which read:  “15 Years Later”.  Oh boy - if I was on a plane I would have flagged down a steward for some extra pillows or a drink.  Actually the feeling was more akin to believing you were on a jet and suddenly realizing you’re on a train. This isn’t the 40 minute air shuttle from NY to Boston but the 4 1/2 hour Amtrak special.  A new feature emerges with a new star, Bradley Cooper, who is a law school educated cop trying to prove something to his politically savvy father who is a Judge.  All interesting enough - and it was connected to the original motorcycle-man storyline. In fact, we have an almost biblical sort of epic where the sins of the father’s are visited on the next generation. In this case the two sons of the protagonists shine. Emory Cohen and Dane DeHaan capture that narcissistic innocent victimhood of high school loners. They are the repulsive, attractive types your daughter might like... but you wouldn’t. Ray Liotta, of Copa fame, actually is in the second half reprising his role as a corrupt heavy - almost borrowing De Niro’s sneer.  Eva Mendes shows an amazing range as she morphs from the sexy love struck heroine to a tragic middle aged mother of a difficult teenager.  Cianfrance has a touch with actors as everyone rose to the occasion. In addition the film is marked by numerous high speed chase scenes which are carefully executed in a ‘reality TV’ manner - it works. So far so good... strong acting, solid direction, interesting (albeit epic) script, well executed action sequences..... Ironically the weakness of this work lies in a battle between the director and himself.

Cianfrance is one of three people who share a writing credit for “The PlaceBeyond the Pines”.  It is is an earnest effort at a grand statement but the director’s talents are more geared towards a more fluid and concise style of cinema.  This film is alive in ‘the inbetween’. The chases, the walks, the struts, the party scenes.... have a natural flair that is lacking in the many plot driven expository dialogue moments... and yes clocking in at 140 minutes - there are plenty of those.  The real question is why should it take over two hours to tell this story (or stories)? Great performers have the ability to replace spoken dialogue with gesture, glimpse, movement...  Cianfrance has a talented cast and might have place more trust in their simple presence.  The sequence involving Gosling’s partner in crime, Ben Mendelsohn, is a poster child for this film’s need for concision.  Gosling’s initial encounter with this back-woods mechanic is the narrative Achilles‘ heal. The are INSTANT best-friends-forever. The one day “come and move in with me... I’ll give you a job and a place to live” challenges credulity.  It is strange that the writing team failed to create a more plausible root of their friendship.  It is perfectly plausible that they might have become acquainted on a previous visit. Gosling’s fling with Mendes shows that he spent time off the carnival campus.  Simply having him ride through the woods and arrive at the mechanic’s camp would have trimmed ten minutes of ‘getting to know you’ exposition. In the second half Gosling’s son returns to the cabin and introduces himself to Mendelsohn.  Once again there is a great deal of walking around the grounds with dialogue explaining Gosling’s prowess as a rider and loyalty as a friend. This all culminates in the son being given his father’s riding glasses as a remembrance. It would have been more powerful if the whole sequence was condensed. DeHaan delivering the news of his progeny and Mendelsohn handing him the glasses while speaking “he was a great rider”.  If the scene had ended here it would have made the son’s wearing the glasses in the next sequence all the more poignant. The discussions and verbal exposition UNDERCUT the son’s search for his father, despite the professionalism of the performers. The actors and scene wear ALREADY clearly delineated - all that was required was a SIMPLE gesture.  It would be possible to recreate the entire film in this manner and come up with an exceptionally strong 95 minute feature. Even the title, “The Place Beyond the Pines”, seems stretched into forget-ability. I challenge anyone to have this easily roll off their tongue after not having thought about the film for a few minutes. Why not ‘Beyond the Pines’ or ‘Robber and Cop’.  The overall effect of over-painting the portrait is to blur the heart-wrenching struggles. We have over two hours of diffuse pathos rather than a crisp penetrating tale of two generations.


‘The Place Beyond the Pines’ thesis revolves around how the sons cope with absent fathers while defining their own identities.    It is interesting to note that Cianfrance has been making films for nearly two decades and studied at University under the pioneer of American Avant-Garde filmmaker, Stan Brakhage.  His professor’s body of work consists of many silent, emotionally jarring, quick-cut meditations on topics usually reserved for philosophers rather than movie-makers.  As a paradigm example one of his major early films, ‘Sirius Remembered’, is a 6 minute silent frenetic film documenting the slow disintegration of the family dog in an open field. How does it compare to Cianfrance’s latest work:  Brakhage made a short, 16 mm silent black and white portrait of a rotting pet: “The Place Beyond the Pines” is a multi-million dollar 35mm color sync sound feature based on a multi-generational linear storyline documenting the trials two families joined by tragedy. In a sense they are mirror images wrestling with transcendental themes of family and time. Cainfrance’s total rejection of the experimental sensibility is extreme to the point of being a throw-back to a old fashioned style of storytelling. Unfortunately the spoken word fails to be his strong suit. I have not seen his earlier work but I viewed a clip from his debut feature ‘Brother Tied’. Once again Cianfrance knows his cinema history as the moment pays homage to violent scenes from features past. The key thing is this moment was SILENT and riveting. This director’s strength will shine when he comes to terms with his film ‘fathers’. One sees him as a figure closely linked to the two struggling ‘sons’ portrayed in the work. He is trying to find his style amidst the ghosts of his predecessors. Ironically his embrace of an anti-Brakhage conventionality served his cause about as well as the cop/DA’s son diving into the gangsta drug life.  Cianfrance should utilize non-chronological fluidity and abstraction in favor of stiff, stage-like narrative. It brought to mind a story I once heard about William Faulkner. His third novel, where he created Yoknapatawpha county and it’s brooding set of characters, is written in a traditional linear style. Interestingly it is an epic family tale in which the protagonist dies the day of his son’s birth. The publisher cut 40,000 words and changed the title. The critics failed to be impressed.  Faukner’s reaction was to reject the meddling publishers and the tiresome critics and to trust his own judgement. He went back to Yoknapatawpha but this time he wrote: ‘The Sound and Fury’.  Cianfrance knows the medium.  He has delivered good results. His crew trusts him. His actors trust him. It’s time for him to trust himself. Maybe even return to a place beyond the Pines... but do it his way. I suspect it will be shorter, harder to follow; but more fun to watch.