the better truth

the better truth

Thursday, April 09, 2015

It Follows (2015)



It Follows (2015)
The Follower of the Pack

“Do you think the band is good?”
“Their hair is amazing” -  a conversation about a punk group in the 1970s


On rare occasions commercial movie distributors pick a project from the film festival circuit and give it a wide release. Last night in Montpelier Vermont,  “It Follows”, a low budget auteur inspired horror film, went head to head with mainstream fair such as “Cinderella” and “Furious 7”. A tip of the hat to David Robert Mitchell, the writer/director, for bursting out of obscure art house screenings or late night cable cult debuts. The film is a strange combination of “Scooby doo”-like child detectives facing off against a carefully designed super natural menace. No doubt Mr. Mitchell is a student of cinema as this work is an interesting combination of well heeled plot twists. A super demon (or demons) afflicts a solidly unspiritual bourgeois American household with a focus on the young ones (“The Exorcist”, “Poltergeist”, “The Amityville Horror”) . The ritual barrier is crossed and the unsolicited initiation spells trouble. (“The Ring”, “Blair Witch Project”, “Dracula”)   The auteur gives enough new polish to the set-pieces to make it an enjoyably spooky ride. Unfortunately it was neither clever enough to be innovative nor slick enough to be professionally polished.  In the end it was so bad, it was…. mildly interesting.

The premise turns the classic “Don’t Look Now” on its head. That wonderful 1970s tale focuses on a man chasing the ghost of his little girl. The protagonist is constantly on the hunt for the specter clad in the shiny red rain coat who maddeningly disappears in the maze of Venice Italy. In Mitchell’s work the setting is contemporary Detroit where trouble comes to you as a personalized shape shifting demon appearing on the horizon. The premise is clever albeit unoriginal.  The “biting of the apple” in “It Follows” relates heterosexual intercourse. A duped sex partner is afflicted with a zombie-like figure that SLOWLY stalks the new casualty. This is spelled out in pointed exposition after a new victim is consummated. The premise is carefully delineated. This walking dead spirit is only visible to people who have been violated. The monster, in addition to being invisible to the world at large, can take the shape of loved ones or strangers. The key thing is that it walks very very very slowly. Think of Frankenstein’s first steps or the ghouls from “Night of the Living Dead”. There are more rules: if the new victim is killed the monster will pursue the original prey and go back through the chain. Once again the malevolent ghost only appears as an individual, although it can take on numerous personas. 

Mitchell should be praised for having the creepiness supersede blood and guts. There are a few moments where limbs fly but the real scares come when these figures SLOWLY appear and stumble forward. This is “the hook” of this film. Those odd, sometimes naked, pale figures determined to get their prize. Adding to the “ tension” is the propensity of those afflicted teens to seek refuge in abandoned buildings or dark forests. Credulity is the eternal enemy of horror films and in this the victory must go to the skeptical audience member. It’s really not worth going into plot points but are we to believe that this group of besieged teenagers would choose a huge industrial building with a public pool to have the penultimate showdown? Did I mention it was a dark and stormy night. (complete with fog and lightning)

This is a low budget horror film firmly rooted in the conventions that were lampooned in “The Rocky Horror Picture Show”. The problem lies in tone. The over the top mood music begs the question. We can all hope that this was meant as hipster snark channeling Dr. Frank-N-Furter. Then there is the truly terrifying notion: Mitchell was serious. It is difficult to separate the flare from the scare. The strange ambiguity permeates the script. There are narrative moments that provoke genuine confusion. Did the protagonist spread the demon to the fisherman out on the party boat? Was the devil vanquished in the pool of blood? Nebulousness born of careful crafting is entertaining. Mystery rooted in unfulfilled exposition in previous drafts of the script is distracting . Why all the appliances by the pool? Given the fact that the spirit is impervious to bullets why not try to electrocute the beast? Was that the original plan? Does the ‘good’ boyfriend pass the spirit on to a streetwalking prostitute? What is the significance of returning to the place where the couple first kissed? This is a low budget horror movie by a callow director but, even with this low bar, “It Follows” doesn’t follow. The actions of the characters are drawn to heighten tension rather than escape horror. The unfortunate script flaws combined with nonsensical plot points forced the feeling of stupidity rather than terror. Not a single parent stepping in to ask a few questions about petrified teenagers fleeing full throttle in vehicles or on foot. They end up as gruesome mutilated corpses. Even the most disengaged real life father might muster up a “so…. I couldn’t help noticing a couple of your friends have been murdered after being tortured and raped. You’re also barricaded in your room biting your nails under the bed when you’re not running down the street in your underwear looking over your shoulder and crying. Just checking in”.  The adults in this film are akin to the muffled sounds in the old “Peanuts” cartoons. All this absurdity is fine but Mr. Mitchell wasn’t talented enough to patch the flaws. One doesn’t worry about the story holes in “A Nightmare on Elm Street”, but then again Wes Craven is a more nuanced writer/director. The adjective ‘nuanced’ is not one usually associated with Craven which might reveal the depth of Mr. Mitchell’s shortcomings as an auteur.  It was also lazy of Mitchell not to include at least a snippet of exposition regarding the initial birth of the evil spirit. There was certainly enough tedious dialogue regarding the framework of the haunting. Why not a line or two… this began with a girl who was lonely or a boy who was troubled…. That might have given some clue to the incarnations of the demon. As it is the netherworld appears to be channeling passengers from a Greyhound bus in various stages of undress. 

Mitchell is obviously shrewd enough to safeguard the golden egg. The goose does not die. The somewhat appealing group of teenagers remain, mostly, intact. There is the appropriate comedic ending of the ‘true’ love being reunited with his damsel in distress. As they walk down David Lynch’s suburban gothic dream there is someone behind them. Does anyone else see him? Stay tuned for “Following it Follows”.  A warning for Mr. Mitchell. Reflect of those young campers in the woods from the Blair Witch Project. This paradigm indie horror film was made for a little over half a million dollars and grossed $248 million. The sequel, “Shadows:Blair Witch 2”, costs $15 million and made $47 million. The franchise died. Nothing automatically follows. Fire the music director. Be more focused on the script. Don’t let the climax blind you into thinking all is safe. That is the mistake your teenage troupe made in your film. Following these bits of advice is a maximum that should be placed on a large sign in the production office: ADULT SUPERVISION REQUIRED.



Thursday, February 19, 2015

American Sniper (2015)

American Sniper (2015)
The Battle for the Home Front

“He's a psychopath patriot, and we love him”― Bill Maher on the lead character in ‘American Sniper’

“Disrespect my son and I’ll unleash hell on you,”  - Wayne Kyle, father of real life character on which ‘American Sniper’ was based speaking to Clint Eastwood and Bradley Cooper

“Leftists such as Michael Moore will rage on, and professors will judge the movie without seeing it — and all that backlash may cost the movie an Oscar — but Clint Eastwood has done something far greater than win an Oscar. He reached a great nation with a story it needed to hear.”  - David French commenting on ‘American Sniper’ in the National Review

“The movie ‘Sniper’ that is made by Hollywood encourages a Christian or non-Muslim youngster to harass and offend the Muslims as far as they could” - Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, Iran’s Supreme Leader

"American Sniper" lionizes the most despicable aspects of U.S. society—the gun culture, the blind adoration of the military, the belief that we have an innate right as a “Christian” nation to exterminate the “lesser breeds” of the earth, a grotesque hypermasculinity that banishes compassion and pity, a denial of inconvenient facts and historical truth, and a belittling of critical thinking and artistic expression. - Chris Hedges, Tikkun Magazine

What does it mean to be an American who sacrifices for the good of the country? This question is at the heart of Clint Eastwood’s “American Sniper”, a feature which is based on the autobiography of Chris Kyle. This much decorated Navy Seal was nicknamed “Legend” for his battlefield skill as a marksman during his four tours of duty in Iraq. He holds unofficial records for being the most lethal shot in US military history. Proof of his effectiveness as a soldier can also be found in the fact that the Iraqi insurgents had a price on his head. This did not deter him from repeatedly re-enlisting despite being shot twice and surviving six separate IED explosions.  Chief Petty Officer Kyle, by all accounts, was a fearsome warrior. 

Some people divorce an individual’s record from the contentiousness of the overall conflict. This is Eastwood’s POV and it applies not simply to the battlefield but to the complete portrait of Chris Kyle’s life. Despite the advertising campaign, the majority of action takes place state-side. This film has more in common with Jane Fonda’s anti-Vietnam “Coming Home” than John Wayne’s war tribute “The Green Berets”.  It is a journey of a man striving to balance family obligations with a desire to serve his larger community. There is a flatness to the narrative as Eastwood smooths the edges of life to highlight what he perceives as the central concern, Kyle’s struggle to do ‘good’ in a sea of ambiguity. Oddly the director eschews shading any facet of the movie. Everything is designed to showcase Chris’ struggle which ironically diminishes the story by creating a cartoonish reality. 

The film opens with Chris facing the daunting decision of whether to fire on a clearly armed young mother and her child. At this point there is a flashback regarding our heroes family. The father is a fire and brimstone Christian, active in his church, who castigates anyone who lets themselves be cowed. Chris had just rescued his younger brother from a playground bully. He and his sibling bear the scars of conflict which prompts the father’s sermon on the obligation of retaliation. One feels more nervous about the blows that would have been delivered by the deacon had the older brother failed to act or the younger one had fled in fear. The most interesting aspect of this is the disconnect between the patriarch’s adherence to Jesus’ ‘turn the other cheek’ ethic, while preaching hardscrabble no nonsense, self-defense. Unfortunately Eastwood sees any momentary reflection on the father’s seemingly contradictory message to undercut the central narrative. The father is not a father so much as a prop to exhibit Chris’ tough upbringing. That childhood included the cardinal tenant of being strong against an oppressor. Eastwood sees the takeaway as Chris being imbued from birth with the mission to violently suppress bullies.  Some audience members might wonder about Chris’ attitude towards his father. He obeyed him…. but was this born of being scared or being a true believer? or both? or neither?  Eastwood wants the audience to simply accept the deacon as merely the guiding influence on Chris. A metaphor for the difficulty of the film lies this minor plot point. This seemingly simple narrative is not simple. This flaw carries over into the wider portrayal of Chris’ marriage and his conduct on the battle field.

There are two moments that reveal the context of the fighting. The first is Chris watching the news footage of the 1998 terrorist attacks in East Africa which killed hundreds of civilians and damaged two US embassies. These coordinated assaults were directed by Islamic extremists. Witnessing live footage spurs Chris to abandon his career as a hard-living cowboy and join one of the most elite units in the US armed forces. Even the most ardent civilian knows that becoming a Navy Seal tests the limits of one’s mental and physical strength. Mr. Eastwood spends a great deal of time documenting the torment of our heroes metamorphosis from tough rodeo rider into gentleman soldier. He meets a vulnerable young woman. Their wedding day presents the second moment that gives motivation for the fighting - their nuptials were near 9/11/2001 - which leads to his deployment to Iraq. There is a conveyor-like movement to the storyline in which context is trumped by desire to present a simple narrative. The unexplored cloudiness of the relationship with his father is followed by a blurriness about this his marriage and the war. Chris respected his father, loved wife and was, by all accounts, a superb soldier. These facts are distinct from his motivations for taking on the responsibilities of starting his own family and his personal feelings about the mission. Where these acts of love or obligation? Or both? Or neither? Towards the latter part of his deployment his unit brandishes a skull symbol on their uniforms and vehicles. It is a visual representation of the horror of the deployment. Yet Eastwood never delves into a discussion of the transformation of a eager patriot to a victim of PTSD. The anguish and stoicism are exhibited but never explored.  

There is a brief moment in the film where the hapless younger brother, who has joined the service in footsteps of Chris, crosses paths with his ‘legendary’ older sibling. He attempts to mask his own shell shock and showers his brother with accolades. He closes the conversation by looking around at the stark Iraqi landscape and saying something along the lines of “it’s totally fucked here”.  The older brother clearly registers that something is wrong. Eastwood shows Chris in many searing moments of pain when comrades are brutally killed, but the passing fraternal pause is the only time there is a shade of doubt about the overall mission. Once again Eastwood focuses his attention on less nuanced readings of horrific situations. Although the battles are technically complicated, the morality is less opaque. When Chris fatally shoots the woman and child, each of them is in the process of throwing a grenade at his fellow soldiers. The director has Chris hold his fire till the last possible moment. In fact there is a tense sequence where he spares the life of another young boy as he abandons his rocket launcher. Chris haltingly rejects praise from his comrades as his moral compass is rooted in knowing that war is a dirty business. He realizes he is not an innocent but he takes solace in the fact that he feels justified. He explicitly states he will defend every one of his shots to his maker when the time comes. This is admirable but one yearns for a sense of Lincoln’s famous answer to a query about whether God favored the Union cause in the Civil War: “Sir, my concern is not whether God is on our side; my greatest concern is to be on God’s side, for God is always right.” Chris will defend every shot.... but does that mean that he believes God will sanction his actions? Possibly, but what about his brother? Or his wife? It is the lack of bringing attention to these questions that undermines the film and gives ammunition to critics who wish to relegate the effort to being merely propaganda. The overly stylized last battle sequence sets an inappropriate tone of action-adventure heroism that crushes the important credulity of the overall story. I have no doubt about Chris Kyle’s bravery but audiences might wonder about the timing of his Iraqi exit. Did he really slay the nemesis sniper from one mile away then immediately call his wife and say “he’s had enough….he’s coming home now”? Did she really hang on the call while the dropped phone captures the James Bond-like escape with hundreds of enemy troops descending? 

Technically Eastwood deliveries a solid, albeit formulaic, film. Sienna Miller and Bradley Cooper give strong performances that rose over the emotional predictability of the script. The movie has achieved phenomenal commercial success and has won over many who are tired of feeling ashamed of proudly waving the stars and stripes. Perhaps avoiding complication is the prefect antidote to the never-ending doubtfulness of contemporary America. Our enormous wealth and technological prowess is countered by a sense of growing economic uncertainty. We are the first generation to make less and live shorter lives than our parents. We have the most powerful army in the world with science fiction-like capabilities. Yet we stumble against shadowy non-state actors that seem as ubiquitous as our Orwellian intelligence surveillance apparatus which seems to focus on ourselves as much as our adversaries. Given this setting Eastwood gives us an unvarnished, uncomplicated hero trying to do good in the morass of moral ambiguity. The closing footage of Chris Kyle’s actual Texas funeral shows how this man captured the hearts of so many. There are rows of veterans, peaces officers and first responders that literally pack a Texas-sized football stadium to say goodbye. In this sense one can view “American Sniper” as understandably one dimensional. Eastwood feels the need to prioritize the suffering of our veterans. In his view their pain trumps whether the film portrayed Muslims in an unflattering fashion. Furthermore the director feels the uncontested bravery of Chris and his comrades outweighs the need to ponder the righteousness of the war. He is not alone. The First Lady, Michelle Obama, commented on how many military families endure the numerous struggles portrayed in Mr. Eastwood’s film. True enough. Unfortunately the black title card prior to the funeral gave me pause. To paraphrase: Chris Kyle was killed while trying to help a fellow soldier in his post-war recovery.

While Eastwood’s film is setting box office records the trial of former Marine Eddie Ray Routh was commencing in the Lone Star State*. He is charged with murdering Chris Kyle and Chris’s best friend Chad Littlefield. Chris and Chad were attempting to help Mr. Routh through his own difficulties after serving in Iraq and Haiti. The film spends a great deal of time documenting Chris anguish returning state-side. Until he found comfort in helping other traumatized Vets, Chris was either in a zombie-like state of recalling the carnage or, more dangerously, drowning his sorrow in alcohol. There is a scary sequence in which Chris loses control and nearly kills the family dog in front of his children and their friends who are celebrating a birthday. Routh was also struggling but less able to control himself. Sadly the last text sent by Chris and Chad was to each other while they were in Chris’ truck with Routh. They messaged that they were nervous about Routh and both needed to watch each others’ backs.  

There is no argument that Routh committed the horrific act. There is a great deal of discussion about the culpability of Routh. There can be no logical explanation why Routh would murder two helpful strangers and then flee the scene in Chris’ vehicle. This “crazy” act of violence by a clearly mentally ill veteran does not shield him from the electric chair. According to the State’s Attorney the fact that Routh admitted in a confession that he knew he was ‘doing wrong’  makes him guilty capital murder. It is an unspeakable wrong that Routh killed these decorated soldiers but the dangers of stripping down the nuance of the situation, and ignoring the fact that Routh was not of sound mind, will amplify the tragedy. Eastwood delivers a heart-wrenching story of violence pain and sacrifice which has been scorned by some who see Chris as a simple mass murderer; just as many would see Routh as an obvious demon who needs to be put to death. It is dangerous to rush to judgement without fully understanding each person’s journey. What does it mean to be an American who sacrifices for the good of the country? The answer to that question can be found in Routh’s story as well as Chris’. There is no equivalence between these two men as soldiers. Chris was clearly a super-star who garnered massive support for his difficult actions. Routh was merely a grunt who fell victim to his dark side. “American Sniper” gives us the comfort of the former and avoids the disquiet of the latter. We can all take solace in cheering crowds gathered to remember a fallen loved one. We should also be cautious of the angry mob who cries for vengeance against an enemy. My guess is that you could fill a cheering stadium to watch the execution of Eddie Ray Routh.  Ironically Chris Kyle would be the first to person to rise up against the sea of bullies. That is the part of the story Mr. Eastwood failed to tell. We are all joined in arms, especially when we are on the home front. When we talk about Chris we need to speak about Eddie. The latter deserved more than a cue card.


* - On Feb. 25, 2015 Eddie Ray Routh was convicted of capital murder by a jury after 3 hours of deliberation. He was swiftly sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Chad Littlefield's mother said:

"We've waited two years for God to get justice for us on behalf of our son and, as always, God has proved to be faithful".


Thursday, January 01, 2015

Birdman (2014)


Birdman (2014)
The Bird is the Word

“This portrait of an artist as a middle aged man is the most brilliant, varied and entertaining movie I’ve seen since Citizen Kane” 
― Dwight MacDonald, original Esquire review of Fellini’s 8 1/2 entitled “Obvious Masterpiece”


Imagine the genius involved in melding the mid-life angst of Fellini’s 8 1/2, the raw emotion of Cassavetes’ “Opening Night” and the existential scope of Shakespeare. Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu’s “Birdman” is that film. The reward for his efforts was a half empty theater on a Saturday night at the hight of the Christmas Movie season. The exceptionally long lines at the multiplex were for “Penguins of Madagascar” and “The Hungergames: Mockingjay Pt. 1”. Ironically one of the major themes in Inarritu’s work is the pecuniary disadvantages of retaining artistic integrity. Poets and potters are rarely in a position where the bottom line effects their vision. Filmmakers and actors must wrestle with mammon. Broadway audiences have enjoyed seeing Patrick Stewart as Prospero and Bryan Cranston as LBJ, but those opportunities were born their work as Captain Jean-Luc Picard and Walter White. The magic of Inarritu’s vision is to acknowledge the seduction of the latter while presenting the arduousness of the former. It is not enough to deride being a matinee idol without acknowledging its intoxicating allure.  Despite “Birdman’s” portraying the battle between temporal gratification and spiritual fulfillment it avoids the trap of sermonizing.  It breaks from the narrow confines of squabbling egocentric thespians imprisoned a NY theater to become a universally hilarious koan. 

The film opens with letters being arranged and forming short questions and answers:

And did you get what you wanted from this life, even so?
I did.
And what did you want?
To call myself beloved, to feel myself beloved on the earth.

The writer Raymond Carver wrote these words as his epitaph. Riggan, played by Michael Keaton, is “Birdman’s” central character. He has decided to adapt a Carver story for the Broadway stage. The film is anchored around the play’s debut. Riggan’s theatrical qualifications lie in his past screen glory as the action-hero Birdman. The opening titled conversation is interspersed with two brief obscure images. Are those sea creatures on a beach? Is that a shooting star or a crashing aircraft? The first visually clear sequence is Riggan FLOATING in the air in his underwear in a lotus position.The camera holds on him in the dingy room. There is something comically absurd about this image that plays against the initial highbrow arthouse seriousness of life questions and indecipherable images. Inarritu will tell his truth with a smile, a laugh and a hearty dose of magical realism. He also emphasizes absolute precision.  There is a formidable technical prowess to Inarritu’s team. Although the action might appear as carefree as a Cassavetes’ improvisation, the lighting, sound and camerawork DEMAND everyone hit their marks with quartz-like precision. A half step in the wrong direction would put an actor out of frame. A misdirected head turn would compromise the audio. But the images and sound aren’t merely recorded. The camera empathizes with the action to the point where it becomes a silent narrator. This is best illustrated in the films rare moments of repose. It is as someone suddenly found a tripod to rest the breathless chorus. We see this in the opening shot of Riggan floating, the many dressing room scenes with the ex-wife or the other actresses, the sudden half minute halt in the hallway to acknowledge the distance applause, or the masterful slow choreography of the confrontation with the daughter.  The effect is to physically bring the audience into the moment. Reading a script of this movie would be the equivalent of trying to understand a ballet through paper-based dance notation. Kudos to the brave producers who backed this project. They were obviously betting on the man and not the written word. They won.

In this film each seemingly random sequence contains the overall themes writ in miniature akin to the way each of our bodies DNA cell’s holds a master blue-print. Here is a small example. Our hero stumbles into a seedy, storefront liquor store which consists of a narrow hallway of christmas lights and a bullet proof glass booth which protects the clerk from the clientele. During the transaction we hear a man raging in the distance. On the grim sidewalk Riggan encounters the source of the howling. A down and out street performer screaming the “Sound and Fury” speech. They lock eyes and street-Macbeth morphs into a desperate actor channeling the Beatles “Paperback Writer”. The Scottish King can do it softer or louder or more colorful or less bombastic. Riggan ignores the street royal and fumbles on in a boozy haze. The only thing that differentiates him from the busker is his stint as the Birdman, which he carries as an albatross around his neck. But that hated role has given him the ability to make the daring move into being a ‘real’ artist with his adaption of Carver. Yet this shot at trying to be genuine might lead him to being destitute and obscure… or worse yet… force him to ‘sell out’ by agreeing to do “Birdman IV”. Is it better to be Birdman than an unemployed actor screaming Shakespeare to annoyed pedestrians? These are thoughts to ponder when Riggan encounters his daughter in the green room. She is a attractive young woman who is recently out of rehab. She  seeks redemption as her father’s Girl Friday during the opening. Suddenly Riggan must assume the role of parent. Is there a smell of marijuana? Has she been using? Again?! Her denials lead to his discovering the remnants of a small joint. He castigates his daughter with all the self-righteousness of an overwhelmed father. How could she betray him at his most desperate hour? Does she have any idea what this show means to him? This prompts the daughter to erupt in a rage rooted in decades of abandonment while the Birdman was flying high. She excoriates him with the most damning weapon - the honest truth. It is delivered with the sound and fury reserved for close family members during the holiday season.  He doesn’t give a damn about his daughter. He is a vain fool who has squandered his riches and is presently embarking on a deluded quest to be “taken seriously”. His choice of Carver exhibits his arrogance born of ignorance. No one cares about him or his pathetic play. To echo Macbeth, he is NOTHING and NO ONE MATTERS. The camera has been patiently taking in the wrath with a steady close up of Emma Stone. A lesser director would have immediately cut to a reaction shot from Michael Keaton. Inarritu keeps the camera in place to absorb HER reaction. We see the brutal truth-teller melt into the concerned daughter. The shot holds in a silence born of a lifetime of pain. The camera follows her tender steps forward revealing a close-up of our crestfallen former super hero. She leaves after he re-assures her he is okay. He ends up smoking the remainder of the joint. The heaviness smoothly shifts to comedy without diluting the power of the scene. Then we return to the bustle of staging the play.  The show MUST go on.

Riggan’s daughter is the least of his adversaries. The fully costumed alter-ego of Birdman harangues Keaton with reminders of the absurdity of his play both artistically and financially. His proposition is clear: participating in Birdman IV is the key to salvation. He may be a crazy make-believe cartoon character but his advice is sage. What sane person would walk away from millions to endure the endless slings and arrows? The critic from the “paper of record”, whom he encounters  in a bar near the theater, vows to destroy his play. Ironically she agrees with his alter ego and thinks he deserves the bird suit. She is offended by a washed up movie star believing he can simply book a theater and produce ‘real’ art. She promises to make him an example in case the minions of West Coast self-entitled superstars get any more ideas. Inarritu builds tension as her bad review will sink the play. 

If all this isn’t enough there is the ex-wife reminding him to look after his daughter and a co-star love interest who is and then isn’t pregnant with his child. Did I mention that his male co-star has been stricken by a falling light? Don’t worry the leading lady’s husband Mike, played by Ed Norton, to the rescue. He is a savior but, this is Inarritu’s world, he is also Shiva, the God of Destruction. His insightful criticism of the script and a dogged work ethic are wonderful. Then, during the first pre-view, he breaks character on stage in front of the audience and berates Riggan. Our hero’s crime was preventing Mike from drinking real gin on stage instead of water. Mike lets him have it with all the candor of a raging drunk. His philosophy is simple: nothing matters except what happens ON STAGE. How dare anyone mess with his prop! His stagecraft also include raping his co-star, who is also his wife, in order to give a scene more ‘reality’. Since there is no life outside of the play itself, he has absolutely no idea why she is upset. Inarritu has him burst in on her having a spontaneous lesbian dalliance with Riggan’s girlfriend. The human reaction would be to close the door and walk away. But Mike’s impenetrable narcissism leads him to give a “guess you’re not ready to talk” comment followed by a giddy shrug to acknowledge her straying. While most would be jealous he is incredulous, why would anyone desire anyone but him? Another of his victims is Riggan’s daughter whom he entraps with heartfelt speeches about “only being alive onstage”. She, despite the shell of toughness, is taken by his apparent legitimacy. Mike ends up getting into fisticuffs with Riggan, but not about his seducing his vulnerable daughter. Birdman is furious because Mike upstaged him and has landed the cover of the New York Times’ Arts and Leisure section. All the art-speak is revealed as a calculated off stage plot to establish himself as the ‘outsider’ actor. One suspects had he encountered the busker giving a good rendition of the Shakespeare soliloquy he would have punched him in the face to eliminate the competition…. but only if no one else was looking. After all, discretion is the better part of valor. Despite being a feckless cruel sociopath, Mike is absolutely charming and a captivating performer. His intimate friends and family might know the truth, but to the vast majority of people he fulfills Carver’s wish of being, “much beloved on this earth”.

There are never ending dualities in “Birdman”, the private vs public, truth vs portraying truth, celebrity vs infamy, having artistic integrity vs. selling out, onstage vs. offstage….  all endlessly reenacted but brilliantly rendered to inoculate the film audience from repetition. The actual closing of the Carver adaptation is a case in point. The scene, which entails our hero discovering his lover in bed with his co-star, is acted out numerous times with different colorings. Despite the cliche reaction to the romantic betrayal, our hero commits suicide on stage with a pistol to his head, the histrionic acting is fresh with every reading of the identical lines. In one instance one might reflect on the contrast between Riggan’s overwrought jealousy and Mike’s real life indifference. In another we might pity Naomi Watts as this is the scene in which her husband tries to rape her. In another we might reflect on the fun of witnessing melodrama or the thematic similarity between the busker’s Macbeth speech and Riggan’s pulp novel rant.  The endless thematic stew is most memorable during the final preview. Our hero decides to calm his nerves with a cigarette in the alleyway next to the theater. The door closes on his robe trapping him and forcing an escape in his underwear. The only way back is through TIMES SQUARE. As our Odysseus makes his journey to the home theater he is thronged by crowds of onlookers clutching cell phones, gawking at his near-nudity and yelling “It’s Birdman!”. The levels of irony are dizzying. Real life Michael Keaton, of Batman fame, is walking through the crossroads of the world. This spot also happens to be the epicenter of fame-obsessed show biz desperadoes clad cheap super-heroes costumes. Keaton, as Riggan, wades through the primordial soup of the modern entertainment business. Our Birdman enters the theater from the front of the house and delivers his lines from the orchestra seats in his underwear while miming the shot to his head with his finger. The audience roars approval. Who really needs special effects after all. His daughter informs him he’s trending on the internet while assuring him this is a good thing.  Our hero nervously feels the distance shrinking between himself and the Times Square wannabes.… or maybe even Birdman IV. But he has no time to worry… the show must go on. Sacrifices must be made. In the end the self-mutilated Riggan soars… or crashes. The critic is won over but more importantly so is his daughter. It begs the question about the cost of being beloved.

Cue the cymbals and bang the gongs. Everything that occurs in this film his accompanied by the jazz virtuoso percussionist Antonio Sanchez crashing away on his drum kit. In true magical realism style he even physically appears in the hallways of the theater. It’s the perfect soundtrack for the lives of peripatetic entertainers. These people bash through life in the hopes of being beloved. Once again it is wonderful to watch from the pit. Close ups are different. The tender embrace of the ex-wife and the daughter reveal all is forgiven in the end. It is hard to know if this is as it should be. Raymond Carver is a good example. There is more writing on his tombstone. His poem entitled “Gravy”. Here are a few lines:

Eleven years
ago he was told he had six months to live
at the rate he was going. And he was going
nowhere but down. So he changed his ways
somehow. He quit drinking! And the rest?
After that it was all gravy, every minute
of it,

Friends and family would eschew the term ‘gravy’ in describing the sum total of five decades. Carver died at the age of 50. Keaton’s character in “Birdman” speaks of his attempt to drown himself after his failed marriage. The moment was sparked by his wife catching him engaged in coitus with another woman. Obviously the Riggan’s  inspiration for his Carver adaptation. Unlike the lead in the play, his attempt at suicide was stymied by jellyfish in the water. Life is bad, but man-o-war stings can make cowards of us all. Inarritu paints all the pain with encyclopedic inspiration from past masters. It might be of academic interest to ponder if “Riggan" is linked with the Jamaican outlaw folk hero “Rhyging” from “The Harder They Come”.  Or to wonder about the similarity between Birdman’s guilty epiphany moment and Lawrence Oliver’s from “The Entertainer”. Knowing the references, however, is immaterial to enjoying the work. It does not matter that those jellyfish sprang from the grotesque sea creature from the close of “La Dolce Vita”. Inarritu is interested in the work itself and not simply being clever. This special film is not for specialists. It’s to be beloved by everyone who enjoys hearing a drum roll and and feeling a hardy laugh. The emotions can be tough, but we are safely in our seats. 


Let’s now celebrate our famous bird-men and women who live under the proscenium arch or on the screen. They take the edge off real life by living out their fantasies. A round of applause, whether they are reciting Shakespeare on empty streets, hustling tips in Times Square, starring in multi-million dollar features, singing to packed stadiums, strumming guitars in empty coffee houses…. Apparently when Inarritu first met Keaton to discuss the script the actor’s first question was, “Are you making fun of me?”. The answer is, of course. We can all thank Batman for having the courage to make a fool of himself. That is the bedrock of all art. Good and bad. It’s not easy for anyone… not even the superstars. On a sour note a bronx cheer to the PR men who filled the trailer of this film with explosions and a flying Michael Keaton. They purposefully tried to fool movie-goers into thinking this was some sort of action film. Then again how else could you escape the art-house ghetto and sustain a wide theatrical release. Michael Keaton knows the drill, and so does Mike his co-star. Honesty and artistic integrity are important. But we always must remember there is a price for being beloved on the earth.

Thursday, December 25, 2014

Interstellar (2014)



Interstellar (2014)
Ground Control to Chris and Jon

“Sometimes I wonder whether the world is being run by smart people who are putting us on or by imbeciles who really mean it.” 
― Laurence J. Peter, The Peter Principle

Matthew McConaughey is a bore to watch. There, I said it. Unfortunately he is the star of “Interstellar”, Christopher Nolan’s latest sci-fi film. McConaughey's performance in “Dallas Buyers Club” was a tour de force but “True Detectives” showed the limits of his force. He has a propensity to ham it up if left unsupervised - see “Wolf of Wall Street”. Nolan gave McConaughey free reign to drift when the actor needed to be fastened to his command chair. Someone might have tapped the director on the shoulder and noted that John Lithgow, a seasoned master of stage and screen, was on the set. Lithgow plays a grumpy old man with nothing to do except yell at his grandkids. He did an amazing job but there are only so many ways to bark at children. Michael Caine, another screen legend, phoned-in his part as the chief Scientist. The other cast members were saddled with roles that failed to test their mettle, maybe they could have assisted Lithgow with the kids. It is a crime that all these talented people were put under the yoke of Nolan and hundreds of millions in studio money. They needed direction, not expensive props. They were crushed by an army of accountants and technicians adrift without a leader. Even Matt Damon, who has exhibited discretion in his choice of material, fell victim. Two hours into battle Matt rises out of a deep induced coma. He has openly expressed regret for rejecting a part in the sci-fi mega-blockbuster “Avatar” which explains his unfortunate decision to participate in this holiday turkey. Damon throws a few punches and then blows up, literally. His character’s fury is rooted in having lied in order to secure an undeserved rescue. The off screen Damon might be equally peeved for different reasons.

Nolan’s films prove the ‘The Peter Principle’. This is business management jargon for the idea that managers rise to the level of their incompetence.  Promotions based on past work are no harbinger of future success as the new job requires a new toolkit. This writer/director started with an innovative independent film, “Memento”, based on a leading character with no ability to retain long-term memory. It was followed “Insomnia” where a California detective is forced to solve a case in the endless sunlight of an Alaskan summer. It was a main-stream commercial feature with big name stars and pushed the boundaries of a detective story, think “Crime and Punishment” rather than Dick Tracey. The serial killer was played against type by Robin Williams. Ironically during the dissection of this actor's suicide the stress of working in constant daylight took a serious emotional toll on the erstwhile comic, leading to a relapse and a stint in rehab. It had the opposite effect on Mr. Nolan’s career leading to his taking the reigns of the Batman franchise and his own high budget science fiction film “Inception”. These endeavors showed strong box office which led to Nolan being given the opportunity to direct another of his ideas, which he penned with his brother Jonathan (who wrote “Memento”). “Interstellar” is a complicated apocalyptic tale with elements of time travel and space exploration. Commercially speaking the Nolans’ projects have shown a general upward trend in gross receipts. They have been given more resources and delivered solid returns. Artistically speaking, however, things ended with “Batman Begins”. In viewing “Interstellar” one wonders whether Robin Williams wasn’t the only victim of “Insomnia”. Plumbing the minds of brain damaged loners and guilt wracked detectives does not prepare one to paint portraits of established super-heroes or create other worlds. The Nolan brothers are better suited to a narrower canvass. Unfortunately “Interstellar” is a grand showcase of glitzy lazy amateurism born of being overwhelmed.

It’s difficult to give scope to the epic horribleness of this film. Usually the craft-related departments come through in these blockbusters. Not in this case. Even the makeup was bad. McConaughey, who plays a NASA pilot/corn farmer, had an unearthly copper hue. This dove-tailed with the flatness of the special effects, astounding for a modern day sci-fi feature. What was particularly disturbing was the blatant  borrowing from Kubrick’s “2001”. Imitation of a classic is derigueur… but a half baked, half assed re-staging? Norton's “astronaut falling into the time abyss” is even more embarrassing when one considers the original was made over 46 years ago, decades before wide-scale deployment of computer graphics in motion pictures. Nolan’s visual impairment is matched by his aural deficits. The sound mix lost all sense of proportion. Key moments of dialogue were drowned out by tinnitus inducing swells of music or special effects. Not that hearing the words really mattered. Nolan has the knack of repeating things in droning soliloquies. If you miss it the first time due to a timpani drum or a tidal wave, you will have four or five more opportunities to digest the narrative. As we drift through Nolan’s universe with this crew of tired cartoon characters, we yearn for yesteryear’s stark simplicity. Nearly half a Century ago HAL was terrorizing his astronauts with simple curt sentences as they breathed and breathed and breathed. This combined with the Strauss waltzes defined the rhythms of space. Instead we are subjected to the tedious dialogue on obscure science or non-sensical plot points. Nolan’s script is designed for obsessive test takers who are interested in passing a quiz on the plot, rather than an audience focused on experiencing the texture of other worlds. There is a madness to the grand reveals in this film. Are we supposed to believe that this passionate NASA employee is completely unaware of a major NASA installation with a few hours drive in this underpopulated world? Are we to believe that the people in charge of this super massive installation are unaware that the leading NASA pilot is just down the road? Are we to believe that the NASA chiefs would suddenly hire this pilot who happens upon the facility due to his 10 year old daughter's receiving messages in morse code from another dimension? Yes, yes yes…..  Which begs the exclamation, WTF!? It goes on and on…. for 2 hours and 49 minutes. This audience member was praying that another encounter with a black hole would speed the clock… alas unlike the Lazarus project heroes stranded on those distant planets, there was no hibernation chamber to shield us from the desolate monotony.


Even the most insipid late night television spot can lay bare insights into the society at large. This holiday blockbuster offers a strange asymmetrical message regarding scientific progress. “Interstellar’s” earth has suffered an unspecified ecological disaster leading to the degradation of farmland and a one generation end-time. There are vague references to greedy selfishness being at the heart of the debacle. Everyone wanting too much which might hint at a call to collectivism. Strangely McConaughey seems to exhibit an abhorrence to the idea that the government, or anyone, can tell him anything. The apocalypse has had no dent in our hero’s solid American individualism. Oddly the this end-time earth bears little resemblance to the standard “Mad Max” set-piece. It is a subdued shabby rural setting. Imagine a crappy small town in the Mid West or upstate NY that is visited by a dust storm every fortnight. It’s drab, but people are well fed. There is a muddled sense of order more Mayberry than dystopia. The government has the same listless quality. There is an odd sequence where the local school teaches McConaughey’s daughter that his beloved Apollo missions never made it to the moon. This propaganda is designed to keep the young people interested in farming rather than technology. This makes little sense as McConaughey’s farm is swimming in high tech automation. Logic would dictate a Federal push against publicizing space exploration achievements would have no bearing on agriculture as a career. Unfortunately we are in the Nolan’s strange universe. This particular storyline makes Pol Pot’s campaign to promote smoking seem downright comprehensible. “Interstellar”, despite the reams of expository dialogue, is riddled with inexplicable reasons for the characters’ motivations. Probably the central incredulous plot point lies in Caine lying to McConaughey about the prospects for earth. We are supposed to believe this former NASA pilot, who loathes his current farm work and obsessively collects space trinkets, would refuse to lead an intergalactic mission to save mankind. All because of his young daughter. I guess the Nolan’s missed the news story about Mars One, the current ONE WAY mission to form human colonies on Mars. Here is a quote from the NY Times article: “More than 200,000 people from dozens of countries applied”. No doubt there are hundreds of parents amongst the throngs willing to abandon their families to serve some outlandish fantasy of “progress”. McConaughey himself is an odd proselytizer about Science’s place in man’s future. He rails against the lying PC police who deride NASA. At the close of the film he has a change of heart. He sits in the old farmhouse replete with a small little league field outside. It is now located in a huge space station orbiting Saturn. He senses something is wrong and embarks for the wormhole to get to his sweetheart. Her partner has conveniently died. His sweetie sits in her brave new world. The odd thing is it bears a remarkable resemblance to the desolate earth everyone is abandoning. One again, WTF? One keeps on thinking - why didn’t everyone just stay on earth and try to solve those problems? This sort of question is never really addressed in the film. Earth IS finished. Period. All the wizardry that assures a successful space mission never applies to the mother planet. Underneath the copper skin of McConaughey’s “down to earth” hero is a pernicious technological escapism. This badly executed, poorly thought-out, feature is really a paean to mankind’s technical prowess. Our answers lie in our abilities to innovate. We can always build tunnels to escape out mistakes.

The Nolans have proved themselves clever with their early work. This film is dumb which is highlighted by it’s attempts at being smart. There is a constant refrain from Michael Caine of Dylan Thomas’ wonderful poem, “Do Not Go Gentle into that Goodnight”. The force of this work lies in KNOWING the fight will inevitably END IN DEATH. The valiance is born in being DOOMED. So why is this poetry triumphantly repeated by the lead scientist charged with manning earth’s salvation? Well the clever Nolan brothers might say that Caine knew the earth would fail. Correct. Except that he had a strong faith in his mission’s success exhibited by the fact that he felt guilty about not having a majority of earthlings join in his careful PLAN B. Thomas’ words sound good, especially when rounded by Caine’s rough English accent. Unfortunately they make about as much sense as the rest of this draw-out mess of a film. It is inconceivable that people who would carefully plot the logical progress in “Memento” would make the amateurish mistakes which permeate every aspect of “Interstellar”. How could this happen? It is preferable, from an artistic POV, to believe the Nolan brothers are simply in it for the money. Sadly it seems this nearly three hour waste of time is rooted in a genuine effort to produce good work. It would be economically more rewarding to produce a shorter film. There is also an excess of heartfelt nonsense that simple con men would eschew. No, the fraternal duo are being blinded by misguided accolades and the Sirens’ call of huge budgets in order to spare no expense for their “vision”. Audiences everywhere can hope that their inner circle possesses an honest friend who can advocate for spare modesty in their next endeavor.  How about a ninety minute film of a father caught between the pull of duty and his tween daughter? Unfortunately one sense future movie-goers are in store for more of the Nolans' magic. The brothers might want to ponder the lyrics of a current indie calypso band: “Don’t need no message from outer space, to see what’s goin’ on in front me face” *.  And maybe someone could send them a copy of “The Peter Principle”. 



Saturday, December 06, 2014

Citizenfour (2014)

Citizenfour (2014)
 A Hero of Our Time

AMY GOODMAN: But why did he choose “Citizen Four”? What does it mean?

LAURA POITRAS: Yeah, yeah, that’s a good question. Actually, I made a trip to Moscow not that long ago, where I filmed part of the end of the film where he’s with his longtime partner Lindsay Mills. And I asked him, you know, because I didn’t actually ever know what it was, and he said, “Well, I’m not the first person who’s going to come forward and reveal information that the public should know, and I won’t be the last.” And so, that’s where it comes from.


This brief exchange between prominent left wing activist Amy Goodman and Laura Poitras unwittingly reveals a great deal about her film portrait of Edward Snowden. This government computer systems administrator is responsible for the single greatest leak of American Security secrets which he copied and gave to media outlets. Ms. Poitras, the film’s director, has a background documenting the fault lines of contemporary American life. She has examined race relations, LGBT acceptance, foreign policy blunders and the never ending civil liberties encroachments by an anxious post-911 US government. She is an obvious choice for a documentary about the most polarizing government employee since Alger Hiss. Ironically she was chosen… by Snowden himself. The film opens with a mysterious Citizenfour, later revealed to be Edward, connecting to her via coded email.  He explains he is an insider who possesses reams of secret government information on nefarious spy programs. The narrative continues and another established civil liberties reporter, Glen Greenwald is also selected by Snowden to be a conduit for exposing the horrors of the US government’s reach into EVERYONE’S private lives. Poitras and Greenwald know this material is literally earth shattering. It can shake nation-state alliances in addition to the security of world leaders. They also know that it can burnish the reputations of the messengers. This type of scoop provides a ticket to the pantheon of Woodard and Bernstein journalist/heroes. The problem lies in that Snowden is aware that his status as keeper of the ring of knowledge inoculates him from serious scrutiny by the dynamic duo of righteous truth. The degree to which the filmmaker and the reporter fail to probe their golden goose is startling. Equally shocking is Snowden’s evidence of the US Government’s scorn for civil liberties. It is no wonder then that the filmmaker never bothers to reveal the origin of Snowden’s nom de guerre in the movie. Even more startling is Poitras’ off screen admission that she failed to raise the question until near the end of the film’s production, “I didn’t actually know what it was”.

This much is known and displayed in the film, high ranking US government officials publicly lied to Congress and hoodwinked the American public in regards to eavesdropping on everyone’s phone calls, internet usage and email. We can acknowledge that Mr. Snowden revealed a complete upending of our accepted notions of due process and rule of law. “Citizenfour” does an excellent job of excerpting the relevant Congressional Testimony and Court Cases. Certainly one of the highlights is a lawyer for the Justice Department casually explaining to a sitting Federal Judge that the Judiciary needs to step aside and relinquish their responsibilities so the National Security Agency can engage in whatever it deems necessary to protect the country. Unfortunately the startling revelations completely obscure an issue of central importance: who is Edward Snowden?

Snowden plays at being a simple man interested in“the people’s” best interest. Unfortunately his actions show narcissism. We meet our anti-hero in a hotel room in Hong Kong where, after feats of computer masking, he manages to  arrange a face to face meeting with the filmmaker and two reporters, Greenwald and his fellow Guardian writer Ewen MacAskill. Once again Snowden is firmly in the driver’s seat. Hong Kong is an interesting choice as a place  for a clandestine rendez-vous. The explanation given is that there is a haziness regarding legal jurisdiction and semi-autonomous Chinese Province would provide Snowden with sanctuary. It is also true, however, that Greenwald has a deep connection to Brazil, a country known for a reluctance to extradite foreign nationals. Britain spent decades trying to secure the capture of a noted multi-million dollar armed robber, Ronnie Biggs, to no avail. Greenwald has a Brazilian partner and, as shown in his testimony before the Brazilian Congress, speaks perfect Portuguese. It turns out that Snowden had a great deal of information regarding the NSA’s insatiable interest in private Brazilian emails and internet use, including members of the Government. Judging by their horrified looks at the hearing one would have thought securing asylum would be a given. In fact one wonders if they wouldn’t have offered him citizenship. Perhaps this wasn’t feasible due to Brazil’s not wanting to offend the U.S….. but why not Venezuela, a bastion of anti-US fervor? Or maybe Ecuador? This country has chosen to thumb their nose at Europe and America by hosting wiki-leaks founder Julian Assange in their embassy in London. The notion that the rule of law might somehow prevent the Chinese, who control Hong Kong, from seizing Snowden is odd. One might want to quiz the recent pro-Democracy protesters about Chinese deference to rule of law. It wouldn’t be possible to ask their spiritual progenitors from Tiananmen Square as they were all brained to death. Perhaps Hong Kong was a clever choice but not for the reasons given in this film. There is zero discussion of Snowden’s choice. This is the Edward Snowden show and he is in control of the interview.

The bulk of the film takes place in charmless upscale Hong Kong hotel room which overlooks a even more dreary array of glass box skyscrapers. Snowden himself blends in with the scenery. He sits on his bed with a couple of days of beard stubble banging away on a laptop. He has the appearance of a graduate student pulling all-nighters to finish a project but without any real nervousness about its completion. The calmness stems from the fact that he is clearly the boss, at least in this setting. He seems very pleased by the attention and smiles as the reporters hang on his every word regarding the scope of NSA’s ability to watch and snoop. He points to the phone and says they can hear you regardless of whether it’s hung up. He lectures them on the importance constantly changing one’s computer and phone cards. Oddly this fear of the boundless power of the NSA seems to be restricted to electronic devices. Snowden spends a great deal of time staring out a large hotel window making him a literal target. It’s difficult to understand as he is in the process of betraying the US’s most guarded spy secrets. It speaks to hubris. Maybe he’s not as clever as he believes.  The choice of Citizenfour as a moniker shows this wiz kid’s lack of imagination. He might have taken Pussy Riots cue and thought of Citizensixtynine as a way of sending an irreverent message,  or even better, a nod to Joe Heller - Citizentwentytwo. It is a tribute to Poitras’ skill as a filmmaker that the movie is watchable. The driving force, however, is the magnitude of his revelations rather than the man himself.

Snowden ducks personal questions by saying that he finds it troubling that so much of the media is focused on personalities rather than “real” stories. The anti-hero wants the message to be delivered without clouding the issues with his own superfluous story. Then why not take the approach of “Deep Throat” and be completely anonymous? Certainly the reporters and the filmmaker would have been on board as they willingly acquiesce to all other demands. This issue is never addressed although Poitras gives hints that Snowden is vain. Not since John Edwards was caught on camera preening his hairdo have audiences witnessed such an over the top male grooming ritual. When the cat is out of the bag and our hero must face the world - he’s takes a long break in front of the mirror in the hotel room. There is an earlier scene when, after a few hours of taping he realizes he has bed head and retreats to fetch a comb and water. The clash between not wanting to be part of the story and being overly concerned about his physical appearance is nonsensical. His vanity, however, is surpassed by the odd leaps of logic when he justifies his actions.

Snowden alleges that he is a martyr for the cause of securing civil liberties. He wants his selfless actions to be a springboard of conversation about the need to reign in the NSA. He knows he must pay a price but it’s worth it, as leaking this classified information is the only road to overthrowing our morally bankrupt leadership. He is the Martin Luther King Jr. of civil liberties rather than civil rights. Dr. King wrote his letter from a Birmingham Jail and cheated death many times before finally facing the assassin’s bullet. Snowden records his interview in an upscale hotel with room service and hair gel. Where is his touted sacrifice?  He ends the film re-united with his blond girlfriend making salad and drinking wine in a yuppie Moscow apartment. The filmmaker and reporters seem oblivious to the cushiness of his march to Selma. Snowden makes it very very clear he is not returning to the United States. This Dr. King is dismayed  that those police dogs bite and the guns are real. There is a long scene in which a group of established international lawyers fly to Moscow and meet the besieged freedom fighter who is marooned in the Moscow airport. Those bastards at foggy bottom have canceled his passport and Mr. Putin refuses him formal entry to mother Russia. The legal eagles explain the impossibility of his return to the homeland. The Justice department is charging him with an obscure WW I law which makes his actions indefensible. In other words if he returns he will face certain conviction. This seems to come as a surprise to Snowden which begs a number of questions. If exposing the hypocrisy of the legal framework of a corrupt system is the point of his actions then how would a public trial hinder the cause? Shouldn’t this be the centerpiece of a master plan to expose the injustice. Rosa Parks never said “I don’t want to sit in the white section cause I’ll get arrested and end up in jail”. Then again Rosa Parks was a real hero. Mr. Snowden is something else.

There can be no doubt that Mr. Snowden’s most publicly overt crime is giving President Putin the ability to play the role of a magnanimous statesman. The Russian leader extends a visa to our self-less civil libertarian. Putin also gives the girlfriend permission for a conjugal visit. Once again the apartment and the food looked better than Robben Island. Prior to the closing sequence, in which the re-united couple seem as they are expecting to be joined by the cast of Friends, there is a sequence in which Greenwald and Snowden meet in Moscow. Greenwald is inappropriately boisterous and triumphant. He jokes around with Snowden in a nicely furnished room with St. Basil’s Cathedral visible out the window. Greenwald carefully feeds Snowdown pieces of paper gleefully indicating which reporters are running with various explosive stories which sprung from Snowden’s trove of secrets. It is too dangerous to speak this information out loud - not sure if they fear the Europeans or the Americans. They do not appear to be bothered by the Russians. Greenwald fervently writes thing down and allows Snowden to read. Our anti-hero, repeats the off-key emotional reactions exhibited in Hong Kong. He is forcibly giddy at the revelation that Obama is ordering drone strikes on the Middle East through bases in Germany. Poitras focuses her lens on the bits of paper which Greenwald has torn up… just enough. The conceit is that they must be careful about revealing that they know of this secret war lest Washington or Berlin seek retribution before the public is informed via the news sources. Fair enough. But why no questions about our anti-heroes present circumstance? Is Putin shielding Snowden simply to spite the West or is it something else? What are specifics of his journey to Moscow? In April 2014 Snowden appeared at a news conference and queried Putin about domestic spying in Russia. (Note: the English transcript of the exchange is taken from the simultaneous translation provided by the Russian news channel)

SNOWDEN: “I’ve seen little public discussion about Russia’s policies on mass surveillance so I’d like to ask you: does Russia intercept, store, or analyze, in any way, the communications of millions of individuals? And do you believe that simply increasing the effectiveness of intelligence or law enforcement can justify placing societies, rather than subjects, under surveillance?”

PUTIN: “Mr. Snowden, you are a former agent — a spy — I used to be working for an intelligence service, we are going to talk one professional language…First of all our intelligence efforts are strictly regulated by our law so how special forces can use this kind of special equipment… they have to get a court permission to stalk a particular person.  We don’t have a mass system of such interception. Of course we know that criminals and terrorists use technology for their criminal acts, and of course special services have to use technical means to respond to their crimes, including those of terrorist natures; of course we do some efforts like that, but we do not have a mass scale, uncontrollable efforts like that. I hope we don’t do that, and we don’t have as much money as they have in the States, and we don’t have these technical devices that they do in the States… Our Special (security) services, thank God, are under strictly controlled by the society and the law and regulated by the law. 

Snowden’s response to Putin’s answer goes un-recorded but our anti-hero’s willingness to participate in Putin’s propaganda blitz is duly noted. To be fair this exchange might have occurred after “Citizenfour” was completed and therefore would be impossible to integrate with the material. However this cannot excuse the film’s lack of probing of Snowden’s relationship with this anti-Western strong man and begs questions regarding Snowden’s motivations. Was this really about shining a light on the NSA upending the Constitution or did our anti-hero have another agenda? Mr. Putin rightly calls Snowden a former spy, a label that is never applied by Poitras, Greenwald  or MacAskill. This is significant in that they accept Snowden’s account as being a private contractor who was appropriated by the NSA. There are numerous reports that he worked directly for the CIA and was stationed in Geneva prior to his stint as a high ranking computer analyst.  Furthermore a cursory view of Snowden’s biography in Wikipedia reveals things that certainly would have helped to inform the “Citizenfour” narrative. It turns out his grandfather is a Coast Guard rear admiral who became a high ranking FBI official. His sister is a lawyer who works for the Federal Judicial Center, a government agency in charge supervising operations of the Federal Court system, where Snowden’s mother is an employee. Snowden states in an interview “Everyone in my family has worked for the Federal Government in one way or another, I expected to pursue the same path”. This family network might have something to do with his meteoric rise, especially considering his unimpressive academic credentials. Edward Snowden fails to possess a BA. In fact he never graduated highschool. He received a GED and had unfinished stints at a community college and an online masters degree program. What are we to make of Snowden’s knowledge of Japanese and Chinese? How does a peripatetic high school drop out end up, before the age of 30, as a high ranking system’s administrator for American’s most powerful security agency? Most importantly, why do the filmmaker and reporter refuse to pursue this line of inquiry?

Is Snowden merely an honest broker who was frustrated by government overreach or does his background speak to motivations rooted in something far more complicated? Perhaps those frequent window gazing trips speak to a sense of invisibility rooted in knowing his bases are covered. It is always difficult to judge the appropriateness of people’s actions while under stress. That said, Snowden’s verbal rumination on the plight of his girlfriend and family were off key in the same manner as his trips to the window. One doesn’t feel the deep loss of a significant other but rather the guilt of putting a loved one through a difficult time. He doesn’t appear genuinely sad. Was the reunion in Moscow inconceivable as he fretted with Greewald et al in the hotel in Hong Kong?  There is one mention of the effects on his government employed family members. He will never be able to see them again. This might be a relief to some but the disingenuousness of his affect reveals someone merely speaking the words. It is neither happy or sad. It is the equivalent of his constant nervous giggling. At times he appeared to be a giddy boy in the midst of winning a really special video game. Perhaps the most startling omission is the absence of talk about the co-workers and people on the front lines. There is no discussion about whether his actions injured loyal American agents or their allies. It is bad that Poitras et al never asked the question but even more disturbing is the notion that Snowden never considered it. 

Poitris wants to represent Snowden as civic minded and without ulterior concerns. In order to safeguard his sanctity all queries about his personal life and his motives are verboten. Unfortunately the facts fail to support the hagiography. We can be grateful to Snowden for sparking this conversation in the way that Joseph Vallichi’s revelations gave birth to the public understanding of the mob. This gangster’s testimony gave birth to the term “costa nostra” and gave mainstream America an vivid understanding of the threat of organized crime. Vallichi and Snowden were integral to their organizations. Being expert tour guides in a sausage factory is not the same thing as being being a honest citizen.

Governments, especially liberal democracies, are uncomfortable with publicly acknowledging the actions of clandestine security services. These agencies rely on violence, lying, cheating, stealing, eavesdropping and committing murder while avoiding the judiciary at all costs. This is the price countries pay for being credible nation states. This unseemly activity is placed under the harmless moniker of “statecraft”. What are the limits of safeguarding our perceived national interests? Congress attempted to address the issue the NSA collection of bulk data with The USA Freedom Act of 2014. It passed in the House but failed in the Senate. Any bill that is supported by both Sen. Ted Cruz and Sen. Bernie Sanders and opposed by Sen. Mark Rubio and Rep. Peter Welch shows a broad degree of opinion about what are acceptable practices. Not everyone in the US Government shares Vice President Cheney’s view that security requirements supersede due process.  In addition no one in the US Government sees abandoning the dark side spying, whether against friends or enemies. This film never plumbs the depths of the argument. It presents straw men to be ridiculed or honored with the appropriate approbation or praise. Snowden is a good selfless man who risked a great deal to bring the awful truth to a somnolent American public. The Obama administration is mired in the poisonous anti-terror paranoia of the post-911 era. Congress is feckless in safeguarding our liberties. 

What if this truth was delivered at the hands of a known enemy of United States? It doesn’t diminish the need for reform. It does, however, highlight the necessity of statecraft. Poitras, Greenwald and MacAskill have faith in this spy and believe his motives are good or irrelevant. We must defend ourselves from our own government’s overreach. One might argue that we also need protection for other governments, especially those run by former spies. Think how awful it would be to have an unmerciful, power hungry despot sow pandemonium in our national debate about appropriate security measures. The makers and stars of “Citizenfour” might think this is fantasy. Some audience members might wonder if this has already happened. Who is Edward Snowden? Is he a new breed of bourgeois martyr whose “sacrifice” includes picture windows and merlot? Is he a giggly, goofy, overly-delighted, callous crusader for liberty? Or is he a self-serving, vain double agent who, by default, exposed some the most important and alarming truths about what we have become? Whatever he is, he is certainly a hero of our time.

Thursday, November 27, 2014

Nightcrawler (2014)

Nightcrawler (2014)
Portrait of a CEO as a Young Man

 …in the midst of a war that was selfish, ruthless and cruel Sammy was proving himself the fittest and the fiercest and the fastest.”
― Budd Schulberg, “What Makes Sammy Run?”

This is just like television, only you can see much further.
― Chance the Gardener riding in a car for first time from Jerzy Kosinski’s “Being There”

“Nightcrawler” is a film depicting the meteoric rise of a sociopathic freelance news cameraman who specializes in recording crime related carnage. The premise is unsettling but the real terror lies in Dan Gilroy’s ability to take this work out of the low earth orbit of the thriller/action/horror genres. This film has more in common with the seminal “Network” than “Silence of the Lambs”. Certainly Hannibal Lector is scary but Louis Bloom, played masterfully by Jake Gyllenhaal, is a more pernicious type of monster. The former enjoys being a devil, Bloom sees happiness as something that gets in the way of the real reason for existence, profit.  Gilroy manages, amidst car chases, bloody bodies and Bloom’s eyeball-rolling grins, to give a commentary on the dangers of our distracted culture. It is an art-house film posturing successfully as a mainstream feature with ironic warnings against the perils of entertainment and the banality of corporate careerism.  Gilroy never preaches. The repulsiveness of Bloom’s vision is exposed in a carefully calibrated climb up the entrepreneurial ladder. Bloom never engages in overt violence, but his actions are as disturbing as Lector’s cannibalism. An audience member might consider an encounter with a deranged serial killer to be a matter of luck. That same movie-goer knows there is no escaping the endless smiling junior achievers, salesmen and corporate shills. Louis Bloom is the embodiment of the unforgiving fine print. There is no way out except endless vigilance. Louis means business.

The casting in “Nightcrawler” is superb. Bloom's hard luck ‘partner’ in his news gathering start up, played by Riz Ahmed, provides a startling contrast for Gyllenhaal’s unstoppable appetite for domination. Each encounter exponentially illustrates the former’s callowness and the latter’s savagery. The final sequence culminates in Riz’s sheepish attempt at taking a stand. This is met by Gyllenhaal’s channeling all the contempt of corporate flack by saying that Riz’s failure to meet agreed upon performance requirements will result in physical harm. Riz caves to the bullying thereby sharing the fate of every minimum wage slave or under-educated plaintiff caught in the rigged trap of economic desperation. His fate is sealed with his unvarnished honesty in verbally disclosing that there is something very very very wrong with his boss and the overall situation. Expressing doubt in your leader’s vision is a capital offense as is the crime of competing too well… just ask the rival news stringer played wonderfully by Bill Paxton. Louis not only dispatches him by jimmying his truck but, to the horror of Riz, records the aftermath of the crash. The old, defeated veteran is loaded into the ambulance while Louis leans over with a cam corder. This is a visual metaphor for those who fail to understand the new dimensions of a competitive marketplace. The only way to survive Louis is to get out of the way or get in bed with him. The latter is the strategy employed by Rene Russo who embodies the mean-spirited vulgarity of local TV news. The old adage, “if it bleeds it leads”, has been replaced by, in the words of the news director, “a hysterical screaming white woman running down the street”. The mealy mouthed news staff might be appalled but everyone knows that she is bringing home the bacon with Louis’s endless supply of snuff films. Russo worn mascara, cigarette stained physicality matches Gyllenhaal’s skeletal creepiness. She plays at being Louis but in the end she knows she’s is a low ratings week away from being featured as a victim one of her leading news stories. Her better self is repelled by Louis but like Lady Anne before her, she ends up falling for Richard III. Maybe Lewis could toss her off the roof of the studio and film it in slow motion. It sounds unlikely but it is the inevitable direction of all their hard work.

Gilroy fills this feature with unorthodox small moments of revelation. Lewis’s complete derangement shows through in polished speeches about being a “hard worker” and “quick learner”. But it glows in the quieter moments. In an early scene a scrap yard manager is accepting Louis’ delivery of stolen metal. He quickly dismisses Louis’ plea of a job. “I’m not hiring a thief”.  Louis is not offended. Anger only clouds the path to profit. He almost thanks the man for his candor. This “feedback” is something he can use. Perhaps the most poignant moment is a brief view of Louis at home. Casually taking part in Ellinor Rigby type domestic chores (dawning socks and ironing). He views a  slap-stick routine on one of the channels. A knight in full armor is seemingly decapitated -followed by the reveal that the suit of armor was inhabited by a petite woman who pops here head through the shoulders after the helmet flies off. Louis, for the first and only time in the entire film, roars with laughter. It is the type of humor more suited to a eight year old boy or an eighty year old man; then again the apartment is decorated with the same pre-adolescent or late geriatric sensibility.  An antiseptic, sparsely decorated room dominated by a TV. Our monster appears, to paraphrase Shakespeare,  unfinished sent before his time… scarce half made up. It is hard to feel anything for someone so depraved but the site of him in that cubicle of a living space almost provokes sympathy. Note: despite receiving an economic windfall from his perverted news-gathering, he remains living in his cell. He will get a nice mansion when his career requires it, not before. It might appear to be the same flashy style as his spiritual brother from “There Will Be Blood” but it is doubtful that he will end up braining an old friend to death in the basement. That would require passion. Louis only possesses drive.

Speaking of drive this film has a wonderful chase scene that is as disorienting as the the idea that Louis is a mammal. In most film bad guys chase good guys or vice versa. This dynamic car sequence has weird guys chasing good guys chasing bad guys. The swerves and crashes are shot from the POV of Louis and his cohort - but where is the audience’s allegiance? One wishes our anti-hero a worse fate than the erstwhile ‘bad guys’ who have brutally murdered an innocent family in cold blood. Such is the logic in a world in which Louis is winning.

Gilroy needs to be credited with producing an excellent film but it is not without flaws. The opening title sequence displayed Robert Elswit Hopper-esque picture of LA. One could hear Jim Morrison screaming “cops in cars, topless bars, never met a woman.. so alone”. This promising opening was followed by a slow meandering start. There is a long series of scenes establishing Louis prowess as a ruthless, slick, fast-talking petty thief who stumbles on the news gathering business by the serendipity of witnessing a gruesome car crash. The mechanics of the execution of the material failed to match the remaining 3/4 of the film. It dragged. The problem might lie in the disconnect between Louis’ super human efficiency and his status as a petty thief in the opening sequence. As the film progresses it showcases his extraordinary capacity to mimic and digest vital bits of information. The opaque references to his origins are equally puzzling. Louis has the ‘right’ answer to all questions. He can make up yarns on the spot and speak the language of negotiation whether he is hocking stolen metal, a high end bike or a reel of grizzly footage. When Russo asks about his history he is uncharacteristically taciturn. Where does Louis really come from? Does someone with his demonic skill set end up hocking manhole covers while he’s in his thirties? It might have been better to have Louis enter the movie returning from a prison stint. His lack of circulation might account for his dearth of achievement. The early Louis seems to undercut the diabolical achievements of the latter Louis.  It would also be interesting for him to present, whether real or imaginary, a portrait of his family. It is the kind of thing he would know would be expected in basic remedial human interaction. What would he come up with? Or perhaps a straightforward rendition of the real life origins would be even more disquieting. In watching endless episodes of 48 Hours and other “women in a ditch” TV programs it is apparent that these creatures spring from Ozzie and Harriet’s cradle.

Gilroy also seems rooted in the grimness of Louis’ world view. There is no humor (or sex) in this film. It’s not that the material screams comedy or passion but simply screaming, or more precisely, recording people screaming, fails to deliver the depravity of Louis. Riz might have served as a human foil. He might have feigned a real connection which would have given more gravitas to Louis’ actions at the end of the film. It also might have made eased the unrelenting darkness of our anti-hero. Truth be told Louis is a one note song. It’s a wonderful, albeit discordant, sound so why not ad some brief major chords of humor. One can only imagine Louis at a corporate event trying to impress the suits at headquarters. There is a touch of this as he wanders the newsroom and people know his name. His glad handing and smiling are as tragic/comic as Starkweather at the close of Malick’s “Badlands”. Louis has mastered the affect of being a “just one of the guys” hero while possessing the track record of a cold blooded killer with boundless contempt for humanity. The reality is merely a poor relation to what really matters, image. It is interesting, in this context, that the writers chose to name the protagonist Louis Bloom. Perhaps this is a mirror image of James Joyce’s Leopold Bloom, the central figure in Ulysses. Whereas Joyce journeys into Leopold’s subconscious giving an expansive commentary on the human condition, Gilroy delves into the dearness of Louis’ mind which is akin to stimulus/response Skinner Box. In this case operant conditioning can be entertaining albeit with less of the grand insight given by Joyce. Leopold is a meditation on humanity. Louis is a study in a particular pathology.

Despite some blemishes Gilroy delivers a film with resonance. Although the media, specifically news gathering organizations, takes center stage, there are broader implications to Bloom’s penchant for replacing “news” with fiction. Life is not fiction, it is stranger. A few weeks ago many publications covering the Ebola crisis tapped the screenwriter for the feature film “Contagion” as an appropriate “expert” to deliver commentary on the health crisis. Who needs a bore with an advanced degree epidemiology when Hollywood can spin a colorful yarn. Given this logic the director of the “The Titanic” might be tapped to weigh in on international North Atlantic transport agreements. There are real life consequences to replacing the arduous hard work of understanding with the distraction of entertainment. Know that our current obsession with Kardashian’s butt can render us vulnerable to ending up on a stretcher with Louis’ cam corder hovering overhead.  We must retain our vigilance. We must trust, but verify while always reading the fine print. We must always have a strong counter offer. We must never take our eye (or mind) off the never-end stream of efficient smiling adversaries. This is the new price of civilization, otherwise we will be eaten by night crawlers.  Over two centuries ago Voltaire warned us: “Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities”. One can imagine Louis Bloom hearing these words and exclaiming in a eureka moment: “now you’re giving me something I can work with”.

Tuesday, November 04, 2014



Moxie 2000 - 2014


We met you 14 years ago in the ASPCA shelter. We brought our dog Stanley as we thought he needed a companion. He shared your status as a stray wandering the streets. He bore the scares of a troubled beginning but you were immune to all the turmoil. They had named you Ashley and you made a grand entrance flopping over everything and everyone as a hopelessly cute sorority sister borrowing the self assurance of that Beatles song “Girl”: “When you say she’s looking good she acts as if it’s understood… she cool cool cool cool… Girl! Girl!”. Stanley was unimpressed and continued his Eeyore the donkey imitation - slowly moping about while you lit up the grey industrial tile. We were sold despite Stanley’s seeming indifference. We christened you “Moxie” as a nod to your dominating spirit. Even Stanley was won over.

You were always popular on those late night walks in Central Park. Leaping forward to greet the other dogs while Stanley held back. You were the Queen bee in the dog runs and unlike Stanley you knew when to run and when to bark - often times the loud bark was followed by a hasty retreat…. often hiding behind Stanley. The transition from the Upper West Side to off the grid rural Vermont was seamless. You found a new hobby - wandering out into the pitch darkness to gaze up at the moon. The thrill of the sylvan night matched the electricity of the city. You were resilient to the new animals, setting and weather. Stanley would cower in the corner as he thought the house was collapsing when snow slide off the roof - you wagged your tale and asked for dinner. You adjusted to cars and demanded the front seat - always staring forward as if the direction of the car relied on your gaze. You also believed that copious barking would ward away all potential threats… which often times included any person or animal within site of the front windshield.

As the years wore on your body failed… but never your spirit. Even Stanley’s quiet passing never dulled your vibrant need to participate. As your back legs gave-out you turned to your commanding voice as the means of participating. This led to many evenings of embarrassment as guests failed to understand how we could endure a dog that never seemed to stop demanding the floor. You were difficult at the Vet. You knew it could only mean trouble and pain. You didn’t understand the procedures to remove a life threatening infected cyst or the others to prevent blindness. You were angry when we left you overnight; but you never held a grudge… all was forgiven with a large meal and a loud bark. You didn’t thank us - you forgave us. And you accepted our apology. We knew you could never comprehend the dark chores of guardianship.

Now we were faced with that ultimate task: the question of ‘when?’. Your unsteady gate and bleeding paws told us “now”; your hardy appetite, endless barking and steady gaze said 'one more day'. A night of restlessly trying to stand was followed by a day of dragging yourself forward. We looked past the sores, the smell and the mess. We tried to tell ourselves that things were rebounding. You were never one to go gentle into that goodnight. That wasn’t you. To the last you were defiantly stumbling and demanding a dog treat while refusing to lie down. We prayed for the quiet goodbye that Stanley gave us… but you are Moxie. That defiance we cherished during deep dark nights became the thing that gave us the most pain. But that is not your concern. That is something for guardians to fret over. We loved you for being you… and you were you… till the last.

Your physicality was our grief writ large. The vet didn’t understand how you could stand. His eyes showed a surprise that we had not acted sooner…. just as your eyes dared us not to. You will never comprehend our grief. But perhaps Stanley can explain it to you… just as you tried to explain about the roof-snow to him. We buried you side by side so there is no need to bark so loudly to get Stanley’s attention. We know you will never thank us… but know you will forgive us. Despite having other rambunctious dogs… it is very quiet here tonight. But we take solace in knowing you have now joined Stanley and are no doubt bounding about the new room… he is very glad to see you… even though he won’t show it.

Tuesday, August 19, 2014

Remarks at Opening of Town Hall Opera House


 August 2014 Remarks at Opening of Plainfield's Town Hall Opera House


The Town Hall Opera House building was our ancestor’s version of Social Media/Movies/TV.  In the days of harsher winters, no electricity and horse drawn carriages a public building dedicated to ‘meeting’ was essential. Our forebears familiarity with silence and darkness would be exceptional to today’s most ardent shut-ins. This is not to say their world was grim but rather it was more isolated and less convenient. The Town Hall Opera House served the the purpose of affirming something larger. This place offered a moment of communion which all human’s crave. That muddy two hour slog to the meeting, or play or concert, delivered that tactile burst of knowing that somehow you are part of something larger; which in turn shaped those many hours of solitary reflection.

With tax dollars having to be stretched fuzzy notions about the importance local face to face gatherings fall prey to solid counter arguments based on cost and alternatives. There are other ways to host town meeting. There are other venues available for entertainment. It is risky to allocate resources to a project that has a troublesome history both structurally and financially.

In order to respect ALL sides and uphold the value of a community space one must turn to a very special kind of leadership. Former Selectboard Chairman David Strong stepped into the thankless void of raising private money and personally supervising an extremely complicated renovation. We now enjoy the fruits of David’s labor. It was a group effort - but he was in charge and inspired everyone with his boundless energy.

Our practical selves can view this as the Town adding value to an asset while sparing the taxpayer an expense. The more esoteric can see David’s work as continuing the much needed building of a broader sense of togetherness. We need creative ways to stretch the taxpayer dollar. We also desperately need spaces to join together.

It sounds trite, but as we become more electronically intertwined, bearing witness as a group takes on more significance. Traveling to the Town Hall Opera House is an act of affirming that we are not islands unto ourselves. We are all part of something larger. On a national level our Founding Farther’s knew the importance of group gatherings by making Freedom of Assembly the FIRST amendment in the Bill of Rights. Thank you David for reminding us of something our ancestors knew all along. Plainfield now has a place to come together. There will be triumphs and virtuoso performances. There will also be acrimony and artists who miss the mark. But whatever the occasion, the experience will be sure to impact our quiet moments and shape us as a community. It is what happens after the curtain falls that counts the most.